All Substitution Guides

11 Substitutes for Avocado (for Toast, Guacamole, Smoothies, and Baking)

Substitution Guide
11 Substitutes for Avocado (for Toast, Guacamole, Smoothies, and Baking)

You cut into the avocado for your toast and it is either rock hard, brown and stringy, or already gone because someone else got to it first. Or maybe avocados just doubled in price this week and you would rather not pay that for a bowl of guacamole. Either way, the recipe still wants something creamy, green, and rich, and you need a plan.

Avocado is a tricky ingredient to replace because it does several jobs at once: it is a spread, a dip base, a smoothie thickener, a salad's creamy element, and occasionally a stand-in for butter in brownies. No single substitute covers all of that, so this guide is organized by what you are making. Find your use case, grab the swap, and get on with breakfast.

One honest note up front: avocado is a genuinely nutritious food, so most swaps here are about practicality, not health. A few of them, though, bring more protein and folate to the table, and those are flagged as you go.

The quick list

  • Hummus — the easiest swap on toast, sandwiches, wraps, and grain bowls
  • Mashed white beans + olive oil — a creamy, savory toast spread you can make in two minutes
  • Edamame, blended ("edamole") — the best stand-in for guacamole, and the most nutritious swap here
  • Green peas, mashed — stretches a single avocado into a full bowl of guacamole
  • Plain Greek yogurt — for creamy dressings, dips, and smoothies
  • Frozen banana — the classic smoothie thickener
  • Silken tofu — for chocolate mousse, puddings, and creamy smoothies
  • Nut butter — richness in smoothies and on toast, in much smaller amounts
  • Ricotta or cottage cheese — a mild, creamy toast base with extra protein
  • Butter or mashed banana — for baking recipes that used avocado in place of fat
  • Cucumber, olive oil, and nuts — for salads, bowls, and sushi, split by job

For toast, sandwiches, and wraps

On toast and sandwiches, avocado is doing two things: providing a soft, spreadable layer and adding richness. Any substitute that spreads well and has some fat in it will do the job. Season it the way you would season the avocado (salt, pepper, lemon, chili flakes) and most people will be happy.

Hummus

  • Swap: 1:1 by volume; about 1/4 cup hummus for half an avocado on toast
  • Best for: Toast, sandwiches, wraps, grain bowls, and veggie platters
  • Skip it for: Smoothies and desserts
  • Health notes: More protein than avocado, with similar fiber (see the numbers below)

Hummus is the swap most people already have in the fridge, and it fills almost exactly the same role: creamy, savory, and rich enough to make a slice of toast feel like a meal. Spread it thick, then top it the way you would top avocado toast. Sliced tomatoes, a jammy egg, cucumber, everything bagel seasoning, or a drizzle of olive oil all work.

Per 100 grams, store-bought hummus has about 7.8 grams of protein and 5.5 grams of fiber, compared with 2 grams of protein and 6.7 grams of fiber in raw avocado. It is also slightly higher in calories and fat, because commercial hummus is made with tahini and oil, so it is not a "lighter" swap, just a different one. If you are out of hummus as well, our tahini substitutes guide shows how to make a quick version without it.

Mashed white beans + olive oil

  • Swap: 1 cup drained canned cannellini or butter beans, mashed with 1 tablespoon olive oil, 1 teaspoon lemon juice, and a pinch of salt; this covers about 3 or 4 slices of toast, the same as one large avocado
  • Best for: Toast, open-faced sandwiches, and wraps
  • Skip it for: Guacamole; the flavor is too mild and the color is wrong
  • Health notes: More protein and fiber than avocado, and the olive oil keeps the fat mostly unsaturated

White beans mash into something surprisingly close to avocado's soft, buttery texture, especially creamy varieties like cannellini or butter beans. A fork is enough; you want it a little rustic, not completely smooth. The olive oil matters here: it supplies the richness avocado would have brought, and it makes the mash taste like a spread rather than a side dish.

From there, season it like avocado toast. Lemon zest, garlic, chili flakes, and fresh herbs are all good. If you have a little avocado left (a half that is only partly brown, for example), mashing it into the beans gives you the color and flavor of avocado with twice the volume.

Ricotta or cottage cheese

  • Swap: 1:1 by volume; 1/4 cup per slice of toast
  • Best for: Toast, especially with tomatoes, peaches, or a drizzle of honey
  • Skip it for: Dairy-free diets, and anything that is supposed to taste like guacamole

Ricotta and cottage cheese do not taste anything like avocado, but they hit the same note on toast: cool, creamy, mild, and happy to take on whatever you put on top. Both are higher in protein than avocado, which makes breakfast more filling. For a smoother spread, blend cottage cheese for 30 seconds until it looks like whipped ricotta.

Top it with sliced tomato, salt, pepper, and olive oil for the savory version, or berries and a little honey for the sweet one. Our cottage cheese substitutes guide has more ways to use the two interchangeably.

Nut butter

  • Swap: 1 to 2 tablespoons per slice of toast, in place of about half an avocado
  • Best for: Sweet toast with banana or berries; smoothies (see below)
  • Skip it for: Savory toppings like eggs and tomatoes

Nut butter is the "I just need something rich on this toast" option. It is far more concentrated than avocado, so use much less of it: per 100 grams, smooth peanut butter has about 598 calories versus avocado's 160. A thin layer delivers the same satisfying richness that a thick smear of avocado does. Natural peanut, almond, or cashew butters with no added sugar are the best fit. See our peanut butter substitutes guide if you need a nut-free version.

For guacamole and dips

Guacamole is where avocado is hardest to replace, because the whole dish is built around its flavor. The good news: you can get very close on color and texture, and you can make one avocado go a lot further than usual.

Edamame, blended ("edamole")

  • Swap: About 3/4 cup thawed, shelled edamame per avocado, blended with lime juice, garlic, cilantro, and onion; add a splash of water or olive oil to loosen it
  • Best for: Guacamole-style dips, spreads, and grain bowls
  • Skip it for: Anyone with a soy allergy
  • Health notes: About 6 times the protein and nearly 4 times the folate of avocado, with a third of the fat

Edamame (young green soybeans) blends into a bright green, creamy dip that looks and spreads remarkably like guacamole. BistroMD's edamole recipe is a good starting point: 2 cups of thawed frozen shelled edamame, the juice of 2 small limes, a garlic clove, 1/4 cup cilantro, a quarter of a sweet onion, 1 teaspoon cumin, salt, and a dash of cayenne, all blended in a food processor until smooth. It serves 3 at about 120 calories and 10 grams of protein each.

It will not fool a guacamole purist. The flavor is greener and more "bean-like," and the texture is a bit thicker. The fix is the same trick the recipe itself suggests: blend in 2 to 4 tablespoons of avocado if you have any, which brings back the familiar buttery flavor. A tablespoon of olive oil helps too. Bonus: edamame does not brown the way avocado does, so leftovers still look good the next day.

Green peas, mashed

  • Swap: Replace up to half the avocado with an equal volume of thawed frozen peas, mashed or pulsed; for example, 1 avocado plus about 1/2 cup peas instead of 2 avocados
  • Best for: Stretching guacamole, and pea-and-mint toast
  • Skip it for: Replacing all of the avocado; peas alone taste sweet and watery

Yes, this is the swap that set the internet on fire. When The New York Times tweeted a green pea guacamole recipe in 2015, the reaction was so loud that even President Obama weighed in (he was against it). But the original recipe added peas to avocado rather than replacing it, and used that way, it works well. Peas bring sweetness, color, and bulk, and they let one avocado feed a crowd.

Blanch frozen peas for a minute or just thaw them, then pulse or mash before folding into the avocado so the texture stays even. Season a little more aggressively with lime and salt than usual, since peas dilute the flavor. On toast, mashed peas with lemon, mint, and a crumble of feta are a fresh, spring-y alternative to avocado in their own right.

Greek yogurt dip

  • Swap: For a creamy avocado dip or "avocado crema," use 1/2 cup plain Greek yogurt per avocado, plus 1 tablespoon olive oil and a squeeze of lime
  • Best for: Taco and burrito toppings, creamy dips, avocado-style ranch
  • Skip it for: Chunky guacamole; it is a crema, not a mash

A lot of "avocado" sauces (avocado crema, avocado-lime dressing, green goddess) are really about creaminess plus acid plus herbs. Greek yogurt handles creaminess and tang on its own, the olive oil restores the richness, and blending in a big handful of cilantro or basil gets you the green color. Per 100 grams, whole-milk Greek yogurt has about 9 grams of protein and 97 calories, against avocado's 2 grams and 160 calories.

For a dairy-free version, blend silken tofu with lime juice, garlic, and herbs instead. More options are in our Greek yogurt substitutes guide and the sour cream substitutes guide, since the two cover a lot of the same ground.

For smoothies

In a smoothie, half an avocado is there for body: it makes the drink thick and silky without adding much flavor. Several common ingredients do the same thing.

Frozen banana

  • Swap: 1/2 frozen banana for every 1/2 avocado
  • Best for: Fruit smoothies, green smoothies, and smoothie bowls
  • Skip it for: Low-sugar smoothies; banana adds noticeable sweetness

Frozen banana is the original smoothie thickener, and it makes a drink just as creamy as avocado does. Slice ripe bananas before freezing so they blend easily. The big difference is flavor and sugar: avocado is almost neutral, while banana makes the smoothie taste sweeter and, well, like banana. Per 100 grams, banana has about 89 calories and 2.6 grams of fiber, so it is lighter than avocado but carries less fiber and almost no fat. Adding a spoonful of nut butter or chia seeds alongside it brings some of that back.

Greek yogurt or silken tofu

  • Swap: 1/4 to 1/3 cup plain Greek yogurt or silken tofu for every 1/2 avocado
  • Best for: Protein smoothies and anything you want thick but not extra sweet
  • Skip it for: Nothing much; just add a few ice cubes to make up for avocado's chill if your fruit is not frozen

Both give a smoothie a creamy, rich body and a solid dose of protein. Greek yogurt adds a little tang that pairs well with berries. Silken tofu is completely neutral and dairy-free; it disappears into chocolate, peanut butter, and green smoothies. Use silken (the soft, custardy kind sold in shelf-stable boxes), not firm tofu, which blends gritty. More on that in our tofu substitutes guide.

Nut butter, chia, or oats

  • Swap: 1 tablespoon nut butter, 1 tablespoon chia seeds, or 2 tablespoons rolled oats for every 1/2 avocado
  • Best for: Breakfast smoothies that need to keep you full
  • Skip it for: Drinking immediately (chia and oats need a few minutes to thicken)

These are the "richness and staying power" swaps. Nut butter replaces avocado's fat directly. Chia seeds absorb liquid and thicken the smoothie as it sits, while adding fiber; give it 5 minutes after blending. Rolled oats blend into a thick, slightly earthy base and work best in a high-speed blender. Combine one of these with a frozen banana and you have covered both jobs avocado was doing.

For desserts and baking

Avocado shows up in two kinds of sweet recipes: no-bake puddings and mousses, where it is the creamy base, and baked goods like brownies and muffins, where it replaces some or all of the butter. They need different swaps.

Silken tofu (for chocolate mousse and pudding)

  • Swap: 1 cup mashed avocado → 1 cup (about 8 ounces) drained silken tofu
  • Best for: Chocolate avocado mousse, pudding, and pie fillings
  • Skip it for: Recipes where avocado's green color is the point, like key lime-style pies

Silken tofu is the go-to base for vegan chocolate mousse in its own right, and it replaces avocado almost perfectly in these recipes. Blended smooth, it has the same dense, spoonable texture, and its neutral flavor lets the chocolate take over even better than avocado does. Drain off any liquid in the package, blend until completely smooth (about a minute), then add the rest of the recipe as written. Chill for at least an hour to firm it up. Full-fat Greek yogurt also works if dairy is fine, but it is tangier, so add an extra spoonful of sweetener.

Butter or mashed banana (for brownies, muffins, and cakes)

  • Swap: 1 cup mashed avocado → 1 cup butter (softened or melted, as the recipe directs), or 1 cup mashed ripe banana
  • Best for: Brownies, chocolate cake, muffins, and quick breads
  • Skip it for: Using banana in recipes where its flavor would clash

Most "avocado brownie" and "avocado chocolate cake" recipes are butter recipes with the butter swapped out, usually at a 1:1 ratio of mashed avocado for butter. So the most reliable substitute is simply to go back to butter in the same amount. Expect a lighter, fluffier, more tender result, since America's Test Kitchen found that avocado-based bakes come out denser, wetter, and sometimes gummier than their butter originals.

If you chose the avocado version to keep the fat down, mashed ripe banana is the better swap. It is moist and dense in a similar way, and it works especially well in chocolate recipes and muffins where a little banana flavor is welcome. Unsweetened applesauce or pumpkin puree also work 1:1 in muffins and quick breads. Our butter substitutes guide goes deeper on which fat-free swaps hold up in which bakes.

For salads, grain bowls, and sushi

In a salad or bowl, avocado brings three things: creaminess, richness (fat), and a soft contrast to crunchy ingredients. Rather than finding one ingredient that does all three, split the job.

  • For creaminess: A few spoonfuls of hummus or Greek yogurt dip on the side, cubes of fresh mozzarella, or crumbled goat cheese or feta. Or use a creamy dressing made from Greek yogurt or tahini.
  • For richness: About 1 tablespoon of olive oil in the dressing, or 2 tablespoons of toasted nuts or seeds (walnuts, pepitas, sunflower seeds) per serving. Both replace avocado's mostly unsaturated fat, and nuts add crunch.
  • For freshness and color: Diced cucumber, shelled edamame, or chopped green peas. Cucumber is crisper than avocado, but it gives a bowl the same cool, green bite.

For homemade sushi rolls, cucumber is the classic avocado swap, usually cut into thin matchsticks. If you miss the creaminess, a thin strip of cream cheese or a few slices of ripe mango fills that role. Mango also works in place of avocado in poke bowls and salsas, adding sweetness and color.

If your avocado just is not ripe yet

Before you reach for a substitute, check whether you need one. If the avocado is firm but otherwise fine, the California Avocado Commission recommends placing it in a paper bag on the counter with a banana, apple, or kiwi. Those fruits release ethylene gas, which speeds ripening, and avocados can be ready in as little as 1 to 2 days depending on how firm they started. Check them daily: a ripe avocado yields to gentle pressure in your palm.

Do not microwave or bake it to soften it faster. The Commission specifically warns against using heat; it softens the flesh so it seems ripe, but it still tastes unripe and lacks the buttery flavor you want. Once avocados ripen, you can keep them in the crisper drawer to buy yourself some time.

And if it is only partly brown, cut away the dark spots and use what is left. Then stretch it with peas, white beans, or edamame using the ratios above.

The more nutritious swaps, and what you actually gain

Avocado earns its health reputation. Per 100 grams, it has 6.7 grams of fiber, 485 milligrams of potassium, and 14.7 grams of fat, about two-thirds of it monounsaturated, the same type of fat found in olive oil. That is why most of the swaps in this guide are about practicality rather than health: when avocados are rock-hard, brown, or expensive, these get you through the meal.

A few swaps do bring something different to the table, though. Per 100 grams:

  • Edamame: about 121 calories, 11.9 grams of protein, 5.2 grams of fiber, and 311 micrograms of folate (avocado has 2 grams of protein and 81 micrograms of folate)
  • Chickpeas (the base of hummus): about 164 calories, 8.9 grams of protein, and 7.6 grams of fiber
  • Whole-milk Greek yogurt: about 97 calories and 9 grams of protein, but no fiber

Edamame is the standout. Swapping it in for guacamole roughly sextuples the protein and nearly quadruples the folate, while keeping the fiber in the same range. Beans and chickpeas match avocado on fiber and add protein. The honest trade-off is that these swaps cut avocado's healthy monounsaturated fat, which is why most of the ratios above add a little olive oil back in. That also makes them taste better. And if you are counting plants for gut health, beans, peas, and edamame each count as a different plant, so rotating between them and avocado adds variety to your week.

Not sure which of these fits the dish you are making? That is the kind of question Eat Well Planner handles well. Its AI recipe chat can look at your actual recipe, see whether the avocado is a spread, a dip, a smoothie base, or a butter replacement, and tell you which swap will work. And the Recipe Playground lets you trade avocado for edamame or beans and watch the recipe's nutrition update live, so you can see exactly what you gain or lose before you cook.

Take the Guesswork Out of Eating Well

Eat Well Planner helps you organize your favorite recipes, plan balanced meals, and automatically generate shopping lists — all in one place. Whether you're tracking macros, managing dietary restrictions, or just trying to stop asking "what's for dinner?", we've got you covered.

Our AI-powered tools can adapt any recipe to your dietary needs, help you discover new meals you'll love, and even log your nutrition effortlessly. It's meal planning made simple.

Start Organizing Your Meals — Free

What to skip

  • Mayonnaise as an avocado swap on a sandwich — it gives you creaminess, but not the substance. Use it as a thin layer alongside another swap, not instead of a thick layer of avocado. If you are out of that too, see our mayonnaise substitutes guide.
  • Peas on their own in guacamole — they are great at stretching avocado, but on their own they taste sweet, watery, and very much like peas.
  • Firm tofu in smoothies or mousse — it blends grainy. Silken only.
  • Avocado oil as a stand-in for the fruit — it has the fat but none of the body, fiber, or texture. It is fine in a dressing, useless on toast.
  • Swapping out butter entirely for avocado in cookies — if you are thinking of going the other way, America's Test Kitchen found that cookies made with avocado never spread in the oven and came out dense and damp.

The bottom line

For toast and sandwiches, hummus or mashed white beans with olive oil are the simplest swaps. For guacamole, blended edamame gets you closest on its own, while peas stretch one avocado into a full bowl. In smoothies, frozen banana, Greek yogurt, or silken tofu each give you the same thick, creamy body. Silken tofu is the answer for chocolate mousse, and butter or mashed banana goes back into baking. For salads and bowls, split avocado's job between something creamy, something rich, and something fresh.

Once you find the swap that works for a recipe you love, save it to Eat Well Planner with the substitution built in, or ask it to create a variation ("no avocado," "higher protein," or just "whatever is in my fridge") so you never have to work it out again mid-recipe.

Weekly Tips, Free Forever

Eat Better Without
Overthinking It

More smart ingredient swaps like these — plus gut-friendly recipes and meal plans that put them to work.