All Substitution Guides

10 Substitutes for Cream of Mushroom Soup (for Casseroles, Slow Cookers, and Gravy)

Substitution Guide
10 Substitutes for Cream of Mushroom Soup (for Casseroles, Slow Cookers, and Gravy)

The green beans are blanched, the oven is hot, and the pantry shelf where the can of cream of mushroom soup should be is empty. Or maybe you have the can and you're just tired of what's in it. Either way, you're in luck: condensed cream of mushroom soup isn't doing anything mysterious in your casserole. It's a thick, savory, pre-seasoned white sauce, and you can rebuild that from ingredients you almost certainly have in about 10 minutes.

What it does in a recipe is simple. It binds (it holds noodles, rice, or vegetables together), it adds creaminess, and it seasons. That last job matters more than most people realize. A 10.5-ounce can of Campbell's condensed cream of mushroom lists 860 mg of sodium per 1/2 cup and about 2.5 servings per can, so the whole can carries roughly 2,150 mg. That's nearly all of the 2,300 mg Daily Value in one ingredient, before you've salted anything else. So when you swap it out, you get to decide how much salt goes in.

The best substitute depends on the dish. A baked casserole tolerates nearly anything thick and creamy. A slow cooker running for eight hours is much less forgiving of dairy. And a pan gravy wants something that pours. Below are the swaps that work, with exact amounts to replace one 10.5-ounce can (about 1 1/4 cups of condensed soup), followed by a guide to which ones fit which dish.

The Quick List

  • 10-minute homemade mushroom sauce — the closest all-around replacement, and the one to learn
  • Low-sodium canned cream of mushroom — a one-to-one swap with half the sodium
  • Another condensed cream soup (chicken, celery, potato) — the easiest swap if it's what's in the cupboard
  • DIY dry cream soup mix — a shelf-stable pantry blend that replaces the can with water
  • Sour cream + broth — tangy, rich, and great in baked casseroles
  • Plain Greek yogurt + flour — the high-protein version of the sour cream swap
  • Cream cheese + broth — the most stable dairy pick for slow cookers
  • Evaporated milk + flour — a pantry staple that won't curdle with long cooking
  • Cashew cream — the best dairy-free option
  • White bean and mushroom cream — the fiber-rich upgrade that nobody will spot

10-Minute Homemade Mushroom Sauce

  • Swap: 1 can condensed soup → 2 tablespoons butter or olive oil + 4 ounces mushrooms, finely chopped (about 1 1/2 cups raw) + 3 tablespoons all-purpose flour + 1/2 cup broth + 1/2 cup milk + 1/4 teaspoon salt
  • Best for: Everything — casseroles, smothered chicken or pork chops, stroganoff, pot pie, slow cooker dishes
  • Skip it for: Nothing, really; it just takes 10 minutes the can doesn't
  • Health notes: About 650 mg of sodium for the batch with unsalted broth, roughly a third of the canned version, plus real mushrooms in place of the can's starch-thickened base

Melt the butter (or heat the oil) in a skillet over medium-high heat, add the chopped mushrooms, and cook until they've released their liquid and started to brown, about 5 minutes. Sprinkle in the flour and stir for a minute so it loses its raw taste, then whisk in the broth a splash at a time, followed by the milk. Simmer, stirring, for 2 to 3 minutes until it's thick enough to hold a line when you drag a spoon through it. That's your can. It yields about 1 1/4 cups, and it goes into the recipe exactly where the condensed soup would, undiluted.

A few notes that make it better. Chop the mushrooms small if you want it to read like the canned soup; slice them if you'd rather have visible mushrooms. A pinch of thyme and a minced garlic clove make it taste like you meant it. If you use regular salted chicken broth instead of unsalted, skip the added salt and taste at the end. For gluten-free, replace the flour with 1 1/2 tablespoons of cornstarch whisked into the cold milk first, then add the milk once the broth is simmering. Cornstarch has about twice the thickening power of flour, which is why the amount is halved (our cornstarch guide covers the details). No mushrooms? Use the same method with finely diced celery and onion and you've made cream of celery, which works in any recipe that called for cream of mushroom.

Low-Sodium Canned Cream of Mushroom

  • Swap: One-to-one, can for can
  • Best for: Any recipe written for the regular can, especially when you want zero changes to the method
  • Skip it for: Nothing; it behaves the same as the original
  • Health notes: Campbell's Heart Healthy version lists 410 mg sodium and 2.5 g fat per 1/2 cup, half the sodium and fat of the regular can

This isn't a homemade substitute, but it belongs on the list, because it's the lowest-effort way to cut the sodium. Campbell's and most store brands sell a reduced-sodium or "heart healthy" condensed cream of mushroom that goes into a recipe identically. A full can still lands around 1,025 mg of sodium, so it's a meaningful improvement rather than a low-sodium food. If the recipe also calls for salt, soy sauce, or a seasoning packet, cut those back and taste before serving.

It's worth keeping a can or two on the shelf for the busy weeknights when the 10-minute sauce is 10 minutes you don't have.

Another Condensed Cream Soup (Chicken, Celery, or Potato)

  • Swap: One-to-one, can for can
  • Best for: Casseroles, slow cooker chicken, rice bakes — anywhere the mushroom flavor isn't the point
  • Skip it for: Dishes where mushrooms are the star, like mushroom stroganoff or a mushroom gravy
  • Health notes: Similar sodium to regular cream of mushroom; check the label

All the condensed cream soups are built the same way, as a thick starch-and-dairy base with a flavor note on top, so they're interchangeable in nearly any recipe. Cream of chicken is the richest and most savory, cream of celery is the lightest and most vegetal, and cream of potato is the thickest. In a green bean casserole or a chicken and rice bake, almost nobody will notice the switch.

Want the mushroom flavor back? Sauté a handful of chopped mushrooms in a little oil and stir them into the soup before it goes in the dish. Cream of celery plus mushrooms is a surprisingly convincing cream of mushroom.

DIY Dry Cream Soup Mix

  • Swap: 1 can condensed soup → 1/3 cup dry mix + 1 1/4 cups cold water, whisked and cooked until thick
  • Best for: Casseroles and baked dishes; people who want a shelf-stable replacement for the can
  • Skip it for: Dishes where you want real mushroom flavor, unless you add sautéed mushrooms
  • Health notes: Fat-free and low in sodium if you use low-sodium bouillon; nonfat dry milk adds protein and calcium

This one comes from extension services, which have published versions of it for decades as a budget alternative to canned soup. The Michigan State University recipe mixes 2 cups nonfat dry milk, 3/4 cup cornstarch, 2 to 3 tablespoons instant chicken bouillon, 1 tablespoon dried onion, and 1/4 teaspoon pepper. That makes 9 portions of 1/3 cup each, with 100 calories, 0 g fat, and 6 g protein per portion. To use it, whisk 1/3 cup of mix into 1 1/4 cups cold water in a saucepan and stir over medium heat until thickened. Start with cold water, because cornstarch clumps if it hits hot liquid.

Your sodium depends entirely on the bouillon, so pick a low-sodium one, or use 2 tablespoons rather than 3. Add a pinch of dried thyme or garlic powder to the jar if you like. For a mushroom version, stir 1/2 cup of finely chopped, browned mushrooms into each batch once it thickens. Store the mix airtight, and since it contains dry milk, keep it somewhere cool and dark.

Sour Cream + Broth

  • Swap: 1 can condensed soup → 3/4 cup sour cream + 1/2 cup broth + 1 tablespoon flour, whisked smooth
  • Best for: Baked casseroles, stroganoff, tuna noodle casserole, chicken and rice bakes
  • Skip it for: Long slow cooker runs — add it in the last 30 minutes instead

Sour cream brings the richness and body of condensed soup plus a gentle tang, which suits stroganoff-style dishes especially well. The flour is doing real work here: starch helps keep dairy proteins from clumping when they're heated, so it protects the sauce from going grainy in the oven. Whisk the flour into the broth first, then whisk in the sour cream so there are no lumps.

Full-fat sour cream holds up to heat much better than light or fat-free, which can separate. If you have mushrooms, brown a few and fold them in; if not, a little garlic powder and onion powder give the mixture the savory backbone the can would have provided.

Plain Greek Yogurt + Flour

  • Swap: 1 can condensed soup → 3/4 cup plain Greek yogurt + 1/2 cup broth + 1 1/2 tablespoons flour
  • Best for: Baked casseroles and stovetop dishes cooked gently
  • Skip it for: Slow cookers and anything that boils hard — yogurt curdles faster than sour cream
  • Health notes: More protein and less saturated fat than sour cream; a full cup of plain Greek yogurt can bring 20 g or more of protein

This is the higher-protein cousin of the sour cream swap, with a more pronounced tang. Greek yogurt is more heat-sensitive than sour cream, so the extra flour matters, and so does temperature: let the yogurt come to room temperature, and if you're adding it to anything hot, stir a few spoonfuls of the hot liquid into the yogurt first to temper it. In the oven, a yogurt-based binder stays creamy as long as the casserole bakes at a moderate temperature and doesn't bubble hard for a long time.

It works especially well in chicken casseroles and anything with dill or lemon, where the tang reads as intentional. Whole-milk or 2% Greek yogurt is more forgiving than nonfat. For more on cooking with it, see our Greek yogurt substitution guide.

Cream Cheese + Broth

  • Swap: 1 can condensed soup → 4 ounces cream cheese, softened + 2/3 cup broth, whisked over low heat until smooth
  • Best for: Slow cooker chicken, creamy pasta bakes, dips, and anything you want extra rich
  • Skip it for: Dishes where you want a lighter sauce; this one is rich

Cream cheese is the most heat-stable of the common dairy swaps, which makes it the go-to for slow cooker recipes. It melts into a smooth, thick sauce and holds without breaking. Cube it and let it soften first, then whisk it into warm broth over low heat. If you're using a slow cooker, you can also add the cubes directly in the last 30 to 60 minutes and stir them in once they've melted.

It's richer than the can and slightly tangy, so it's best when you want the dish creamy rather than just bound together. A spoonful of browned mushrooms, some garlic, and black pepper turn it into a very good mushroom sauce. Neufchâtel or a "1/3 less fat" cream cheese works too and is a little lighter. See our cream cheese guide if you're out of that as well.

Evaporated Milk + Flour

  • Swap: 1 can condensed soup → 1 cup evaporated milk + 2 tablespoons flour (or 1 tablespoon cornstarch) + 1/4 cup broth, simmered until thick
  • Best for: Slow cookers, mac and cheese, scalloped potatoes, creamy soups
  • Skip it for: Dishes where a faintly caramelized dairy note would clash
  • Health notes: No added oil, and evaporated milk brings protein and calcium; choose the fat-free can to lighten it further

Evaporated milk is milk with about 60 percent of its water removed, and that concentration is exactly why it holds up through long cooking without separating the way regular milk can. That makes it a smart shelf-stable stand-in for slow cooker recipes. Whisk the flour into the broth, add the evaporated milk, and simmer for a few minutes until it coats a spoon.

The can has a slightly cooked, sweet-dairy flavor that vanishes in a cheesy or potato dish but can be noticeable in something delicate. Brown some mushrooms and onion first, and make the sauce in the same pan, to give it more savory depth. Our evaporated milk guide has more ways to use it.

Cashew Cream (Dairy-Free)

  • Swap: 1 can condensed soup → 1/2 cup raw cashews (soaked 30 minutes in hot water, drained) blended with 3/4 cup broth until completely smooth, plus 1/2 cup finely chopped, browned mushrooms
  • Best for: Dairy-free and vegan casseroles, green bean casserole, stroganoff, slow cooker dishes
  • Skip it for: Nut-free kitchens (soaked sunflower seeds are the usual workaround)
  • Health notes: Unsaturated fat in place of dairy fat; the sodium is whatever your broth brings

Blended cashews make a thick, neutral, genuinely creamy base, and they don't curdle, so they handle oven and slow cooker heat without any of the tempering that dairy needs. A high-speed blender gives the smoothest result. With a regular blender, soak the cashews longer (a few hours, or overnight in the fridge) so they break down fully. Stir in the mushrooms after blending for texture, or blend them in for a smoother sauce. A teaspoon of soy sauce or a pinch of onion powder rounds out the savory flavor.

If you'd rather have a tested from-scratch recipe, this vegan condensed cream of mushroom simmers mushrooms, red lentils, and cashews together and blends them into three can-sized jars. The author uses each jar one-to-one for a can of Campbell's.

Which Substitute for Which Dish

Most of these work in most recipes, but some dishes are pickier than others. Here's how to choose.

Baked casseroles (green bean, tuna noodle, chicken and rice)

This is the easy case. Any thick, creamy substitute works, because the oven heat is moderate and the bake is short. The homemade mushroom sauce is the best match. Sour cream or Greek yogurt with flour gives a tangier, richer result, and cashew cream is the dairy-free answer. For a full worked example, our healthier green bean casserole replaces the can with a homemade cremini sauce and scores every swap, and our tuna noodle casserole makeover does the same with a quick mushroom béchamel.

Slow cookers (pot roast, crockpot chicken, pork chops)

Long, unattended heat is hard on most dairy. Milk, sour cream, and yogurt can curdle over hours of cooking, which is why slow cooker recipes so often call for the can: its starches and stabilizers keep it smooth. Your best options are the homemade sauce (the flour roux protects it), cream cheese, evaporated milk, or cashew cream. If you want to use sour cream or yogurt, cook the dish without it and stir it in during the last 15 to 30 minutes, after tempering it with some of the hot liquid.

Gravies and smothered dishes

Here you want something that pours rather than binds. Make the homemade sauce and thin it with another 1/2 to 3/4 cup of broth, or make it in the same skillet you browned the meat in so the drippings flavor it. The dry mix also makes a quick gravy with a little extra water. For a darker gravy, let the flour cook in the fat until it smells nutty and turns light tan before adding liquid.

Soups

If a recipe uses condensed soup as a soup base, the homemade sauce or the dry mix thinned with extra milk or broth gives you the same result. The white bean cream below is also a great soup thickener.

Healthier Upgrade: White Bean and Mushroom Cream

  • Swap: 1 can condensed soup → 1 cup drained canned cannellini beans + 1/3 to 1/2 cup broth, blended smooth, plus 1/2 cup finely chopped, browned mushrooms and a little garlic
  • Best for: Baked casseroles, slow cooker dishes, creamy soups
  • Skip it for: Recipes where you want a truly neutral dairy flavor, or anyone avoiding beans
  • Health notes: A 1/2 cup of canned cannellini beans carries about 8 g of fiber and 6 g of protein, so a can's worth of this sauce brings roughly 16 g of fiber and 12 g of protein to the dish

This is the swap for when you'd like the casserole to give you something back. Blended white beans are thick, silky, and mild, and once they're seasoned and mixed with browned mushrooms they disappear into a casserole. Most people taste "creamy," not "beans." You also add a plant (two, counting the mushrooms) to a dish that usually has one or two. Rinse the beans first to wash off some of the canning liquid's sodium, or buy no-salt-added beans.

Be honest with yourself about the result: the sauce is a little denser and earthier than the canned soup, and it won't have the glossy, gelatinous texture of the original. In a green bean casserole topped with crispy onions, or a chicken and broccoli bake, that difference is easy to live with. If you're curious what a swap like this actually does to a recipe, that's precisely the question the Eat Well Planner Recipe Playground answers: you can swap the can for beans and watch the nutrition score, fiber, and sodium change live before you commit.

Take the Guesswork Out of Eating Well

Eat Well Planner helps you organize your favorite recipes, plan balanced meals, and automatically generate shopping lists — all in one place. Whether you're tracking macros, managing dietary restrictions, or just trying to stop asking "what's for dinner?", we've got you covered.

Our AI-powered tools can adapt any recipe to your dietary needs, help you discover new meals you'll love, and even log your nutrition effortlessly. It's meal planning made simple.

Start Organizing Your Meals — Free

What Not to Use

  • Ready-to-serve (not condensed) cream of mushroom soup. It's already diluted, so it's far too thin to bind a casserole. If it's all you have, simmer about 2 cups down to 1 1/4 cups, or thicken it with a slurry of 1 tablespoon cornstarch and 2 tablespoons cold water.
  • Plain milk or cream on its own. Without a thickener, it won't bind anything. A casserole made with milk alone comes out of the oven soupy. Always add flour or cornstarch.
  • Jarred Alfredo sauce. It's thick enough, but the strong Parmesan-and-garlic flavor changes the dish, and a can's worth of many jarred sauces carries nearly as much sodium as the soup you're replacing.
  • Light or fat-free sour cream or yogurt, unstabilized. Low-fat dairy separates fastest under heat. If you use it, add the flour and keep the heat gentle.
  • Mushroom soup mix packets (the dry onion-soup style). These are mostly salt and flavoring, not a creamy base, and they can push the sodium of a dish well past the original can.

Make Any of These Fit Your Recipe

Condensed cream of mushroom soup is one of the most forgiving ingredients to replace, because its jobs are simple: thicken, enrich, and season. The 10-minute homemade sauce covers almost every recipe and cuts the sodium by about two-thirds. The cream cheese and evaporated milk versions handle the slow cooker. Cashew cream covers dairy-free cooking, and the white bean version quietly adds fiber and protein to dishes that usually have very little.

If you're not sure which one suits the recipe in front of you, the Eat Well Planner AI recipe chat can help. Import or open the recipe, tell it "I don't have cream of mushroom soup" or "make this without canned soup," and it'll recommend the swap that fits that dish with the full recipe in context, including adjusting the salt elsewhere. If you want the change worked into the whole recipe, Recipe Variations rewrites it for you, and Make It Healthier will suggest swaps like the homemade sauce or white beans on its own and verify the nutritional gain before it shows you the change.

Weekly Tips, Free Forever

Eat Better Without
Overthinking It

More kitchen problem-solvers like these — plus gut-friendly recipes and meal plans for the holiday table and beyond.