All Substitution Guides

10 Substitutes for Italian Seasoning (for Sauces, Roasts, Dressings, and Garlic Bread)

Substitution Guide
10 Substitutes for Italian Seasoning (for Sauces, Roasts, Dressings, and Garlic Bread)

The sauce is simmering, the garlic smells right, and the recipe says "add 1 tablespoon Italian seasoning." You shake the jar and get a sad puff of green dust. Italian seasoning is one of those pantry staples nobody thinks about until it runs out, and it shows up in everything from marinara to roasted chicken to the garlic bread on the side.

Here is the good news: Italian seasoning is not a mystery ingredient. It is a mix of common dried herbs, and you very likely have at least two of them in the cabinet right now. With oregano and basil alone you can cover most recipes, and with a few more jars you can make a blend that is as good as the store-bought kind, or better.

The best pick still depends on the dish. A tomato sauce wants oregano and basil up front, a roast chicken wants thyme and rosemary, and a salad dressing or garlic bread is where fresh herbs really shine. All ratios below assume the recipe calls for dried Italian seasoning, measured in teaspoons or tablespoons.

The Quick List

  • Homemade Italian seasoning — the closest match, mixed in two minutes from five dried herbs
  • Dried oregano + dried basil — the best two-jar fix, especially for tomato sauces and pizza
  • A single dried herb — oregano for sauces, thyme for chicken and vegetables, basil when you want it mild
  • Fresh herbs — use about three times as much; best for dressings, garlic bread and finishing
  • Herbes de Provence — very close for roasting and stews; watch the lavender in tomato sauce
  • Pizza seasoning — basically Italian seasoning plus garlic and chile flakes
  • Greek seasoning — oregano-forward and good on chicken and vegetables, but usually salted
  • Poultry seasoning — a sage-heavy cousin for roast chicken, stuffing and soups
  • Za'atar — thyme-and-oregano flavor with tang and sesame, for roasted vegetables and bread
  • Basil pesto — a flavor shortcut for sauces, dressings and garlic bread

What Italian Seasoning Actually Is

Despite the name, Italian seasoning is an American pantry blend, not something an Italian grandmother would reach for. Cooks in Italy tend to use one or two herbs at a time, often fresh. The jarred blend is a convenience: a balanced mix of Mediterranean dried herbs that tastes right in Italian-American food.

Most versions are built on oregano and basil, with thyme, rosemary and marjoram in supporting roles. Some brands go further: McCormick's standard blend lists marjoram, basil, rosemary, thyme, oregano, savory and sage, while other jars add garlic powder, onion powder or red pepper flakes. As Tasting Table puts it, Italian and Tuscan blends "are more oregano- and basil-forward" than herbes de Provence, which is the useful thing to remember when you improvise. Get the oregano and basil right and the rest is fine-tuning.

Match the Substitute to the Dish

  • Tomato sauces, soups, lasagna, meatballs and pizza — homemade blend, oregano + basil, oregano alone, pizza seasoning
  • Roasted chicken, pork, potatoes and vegetables — homemade blend, herbes de Provence, thyme alone, Greek seasoning, poultry seasoning, za'atar
  • Salad dressings, marinades and garlic bread — fresh herbs, homemade blend, oregano + basil, pesto
  • Bread dough, focaccia and crackers — homemade blend, herbes de Provence, za'atar on top
  • Finishing, sprinkled over the top — fresh herbs or a little dried oregano; dried blends taste dusty if they never touch heat or liquid

Homemade Italian Seasoning

  • Swap: 1 tablespoon Italian seasoning → 1 teaspoon dried oregano + 1 teaspoon dried basil + 1/2 teaspoon dried thyme + 1/4 teaspoon dried rosemary (crushed) + 1/4 teaspoon dried marjoram (or more oregano). Use it 1:1.
  • Best for: Everything Italian seasoning does: sauces, soups, roasts, marinades, dressings, bread
  • Skip it for: Nothing in particular. If you have the herbs, this is the one to use.

Recipes for homemade Italian seasoning vary a lot, and that is fine; the store-bought jars vary too. The mix above keeps oregano and basil in charge and uses smaller amounts of thyme and rosemary, which are the two herbs most likely to take over if you add too much. Rosemary deserves special attention: dried rosemary needles are hard and pointy, so crush them between your fingers or with the back of a spoon before measuring, or you will be picking splinters out of your sauce.

Missing marjoram is no problem. It tastes like a softer, sweeter oregano, so just use a little more oregano. If you want a whole jar, scale it up: 2 tablespoons each of oregano and basil, 1 tablespoon thyme, and 1 1/2 teaspoons each of crushed rosemary and marjoram makes about 6 tablespoons. Add 1 teaspoon garlic powder or 1/2 teaspoon red pepper flakes if you like the versions that include them. Dried herbs fade over months, not days, so if your jars have been open for a couple of years, use a little more and taste.

Dried Oregano + Dried Basil

  • Swap: 1 teaspoon Italian seasoning → 1/2 teaspoon dried basil + 1/2 teaspoon dried oregano, plus a pinch of thyme if you have it
  • Best for: Marinara, pizza sauce, minestrone, lasagna, meatballs, Italian dressing
  • Skip it for: Nothing major, though roast chicken and potatoes miss the thyme and rosemary a little

If you only have two jars, these are the two to have. Oregano gives the blend its savory, slightly peppery backbone, and basil adds the sweet, almost minty note people associate with tomato sauce. Together they taste like Italian seasoning to most people, especially in anything with tomatoes, garlic and olive oil.

Dried oregano is the stronger of the two, so if your oregano is fresh and punchy, tilt the mix toward basil: 2/3 teaspoon basil to 1/3 teaspoon oregano. For a more rounded flavor in a roast or a stew, add a small pinch of thyme or crushed rosemary. And if you are making a vinaigrette, let the dressing sit for 15 to 30 minutes before serving so the dried herbs have time to soften and release their flavor into the oil and vinegar.

A Single Dried Herb

  • Swap: 1 teaspoon Italian seasoning → 3/4 teaspoon dried oregano, 3/4 teaspoon dried thyme, or 1 teaspoon dried basil. Taste and add more at the end.
  • Best for: Oregano in tomato sauces, pizza, chili and Greek-style dishes; thyme on chicken, pork, roasted vegetables, beans and soups; basil in tomato dishes and dressings where you want it mild
  • Skip it for: Rosemary or sage on their own at full strength; both dominate quickly

One herb will not taste exactly like the blend, but it beats leaving the seasoning out, and the right herb for the dish gets you surprisingly close. Oregano is the best single stand-in for tomato-based food. Thyme is the best single stand-in for roasted meat and vegetables, since it is earthy and savory without being aggressive. Basil is the mildest, so you can use it at full strength.

Starting at about three-quarters of the amount for the stronger herbs keeps one flavor from taking over the dish. You can always add more near the end of cooking. If dried rosemary is the only herb you have, use about a quarter of the amount (1/4 teaspoon per teaspoon of Italian seasoning), crush it well, and save it for roasts and potatoes. For more ideas on using rosemary, our rosemary substitutes guide covers how it behaves in different dishes.

Fresh Herbs

  • Swap: 1 teaspoon Italian seasoning → 1 tablespoon finely chopped fresh herbs, about 1 1/2 teaspoons basil or parsley, 1 teaspoon oregano and 1/2 teaspoon thyme or rosemary
  • Best for: Salad dressings, marinades, garlic bread, bruschetta, finishing pasta, soups and pizza
  • Skip it for: Dry rubs and spice blends, and long-baked dishes where delicate herbs like basil turn dark and fade

Fresh herbs contain a lot of water, so you need more of them. The standard rule, which University of Illinois Extension spells out, is about three times as much fresh as dried, a 3:1 ratio, so 1 tablespoon of chopped fresh herbs for each teaspoon of dried. Fresh herbs bring a brighter, greener flavor than dried, which makes this an upgrade in dressings and quick dishes, not a compromise.

Timing matters more with fresh herbs. Sturdy herbs like rosemary, thyme and oregano can go in early and hold up to a long simmer or a hot oven. Soft herbs like basil and parsley lose their flavor and color with long cooking, so stir them in during the last few minutes or scatter them on top just before serving. If a sauce needs a long simmer, add the woody herbs at the start and the basil at the end. Our basil substitutes guide and parsley substitutes guide go deeper on each herb, and if you have a bunch wilting in the fridge, here is how to stop letting fresh herbs die in the fridge.

Take the Guesswork Out of Eating Well

Eat Well Planner helps you organize your favorite recipes, plan balanced meals, and automatically generate shopping lists — all in one place. Whether you're tracking macros, managing dietary restrictions, or just trying to stop asking "what's for dinner?", we've got you covered.

Our AI-powered tools can adapt any recipe to your dietary needs, help you discover new meals you'll love, and even log your nutrition effortlessly. It's meal planning made simple.

Start Organizing Your Meals — Free

Herbes de Provence

  • Swap: 1 teaspoon Italian seasoning → 1 teaspoon herbes de Provence for roasts, stews and bread; 3/4 teaspoon plus a pinch of dried basil or oregano for tomato sauces
  • Best for: Roast chicken, pork, roasted potatoes and vegetables, white bean stews, focaccia
  • Skip it for: Delicate tomato sauces and dressings if your blend has a lot of lavender

Herbes de Provence is the closest commercial blend to Italian seasoning. Both usually contain thyme, rosemary, oregano and marjoram. The main differences are that herbes de Provence often contains savory and, in many versions, lavender, and it usually has little or no basil. Tasting Table notes that the lavender "produces a different flavor," and it is the thing to watch. On a roast chicken, a pan of potatoes or a loaf of focaccia, the floral note is a pleasant bonus. In a quick marinara, it can taste a bit like soap.

Look at your jar: if you can see small purple-gray buds, that is lavender. You can pick out the most obvious ones, or use slightly less of the blend and add a pinch of basil or oregano to pull it back toward Italian. Lavender-free versions of herbes de Provence work as a 1:1 swap almost anywhere.

Pizza Seasoning

  • Swap: 1 teaspoon Italian seasoning → 1 teaspoon pizza seasoning; reduce the garlic and red pepper flakes in the recipe if the blend already contains them
  • Best for: Pizza sauce, marinara, meatballs, garlic bread, roasted vegetables
  • Skip it for: Mild dishes or kids' food if your blend is heavy on chile flakes

Pizza seasoning is essentially Italian seasoning with extras: usually oregano and basil plus garlic, onion, chile flakes and sometimes fennel or Parmesan. That makes it an easy swap for anything tomato-based. The garlic and heat may even save you a step.

Check the label before you measure. Some pizza seasonings contain salt or dried cheese, and if salt is listed near the top, cut back on the salt in the recipe. Fennel seed gives a sausage-like flavor that is great in meatballs and pasta sauce but a little odd in a salad dressing.

Greek Seasoning

  • Swap: 1 teaspoon Italian seasoning → 1 teaspoon Greek seasoning, and cut about 1/4 teaspoon salt from the recipe if the blend contains salt
  • Best for: Chicken, lamb, roasted vegetables and potatoes, vinaigrettes, grain bowls
  • Skip it for: Tomato sauces where you need a clearly Italian flavor, and anything you have already salted fully

Greek seasoning shares Italian seasoning's oregano backbone and usually adds garlic, onion, black pepper and sometimes lemon, mint or dill. On grilled chicken or a tray of roasted vegetables, it works beautifully, and the lemony note is a bonus in a vinaigrette.

The catch is salt. Many Greek blends are seasoning mixes rather than pure herbs. McCormick's Greek seasoning, for example, lists garlic, sea salt and sugar alongside its herbs. Plain dried herbs contain almost no sodium, so when you swap in a salted blend, taste before adding the recipe's salt.

Poultry Seasoning

  • Swap: 1 teaspoon Italian seasoning → 3/4 teaspoon poultry seasoning, plus a pinch of oregano or basil if you have it
  • Best for: Roast chicken and turkey, stuffing, chicken soup, pork chops, white bean and vegetable soups
  • Skip it for: Tomato sauces, pizza and dressings, where sage tastes out of place

Poultry seasoning is usually built on sage and thyme, with marjoram, rosemary, black pepper and sometimes nutmeg. It shares several herbs with Italian seasoning but leads with sage, so it tastes more like Thanksgiving than marinara. In a roast or a soup, that is a perfectly good trade.

Use a little less than the recipe calls for, since sage is strong and slightly bitter in large amounts. A pinch of oregano or basil brings it closer to the Italian side if you are using it in a chicken dish meant to taste Italian.

Za'atar

  • Swap: 1 teaspoon Italian seasoning → 1 teaspoon za'atar, and cut the salt slightly if the blend contains salt
  • Best for: Roasted vegetables and chickpeas, chicken, flatbread and focaccia, olive oil for dipping, eggs
  • Skip it for: Tomato sauces and soups, where the sesame seeds and tang feel out of place

Za'atar is both the name of a wild herb related to thyme and oregano and a Middle Eastern blend made from it (or from thyme and oregano), with sumac and toasted sesame seeds. The herb side tastes close to Italian seasoning, and the sumac adds a lemony tang. On roasted vegetables or a sheet pan of chicken, it is a terrific stand-in that makes the dish taste a little different, in a good way.

Mixed into olive oil, it also makes a fine dip for bread, which is a reasonable replacement for an Italian herb dip. It is not the right choice for a pot of marinara.

Basil Pesto

  • Swap: 1 teaspoon Italian seasoning → 1 tablespoon basil pesto, stirred in near the end of cooking; reduce the oil and cheese in the recipe slightly
  • Best for: Tomato sauces and soups, salad dressings, garlic bread, pasta salads, roasted vegetables after cooking
  • Skip it for: Dry rubs, bread doughs and anything that needs a dry seasoning

Pesto is a jar of fresh basil, garlic, olive oil, pine nuts and Parmesan, so it brings herb flavor along with richness and saltiness. A spoonful stirred into a tomato soup or whisked into a vinaigrette gives you the herby Italian flavor you were after in one step. Spread on bread before toasting, it makes excellent garlic bread.

Since pesto is mostly oil, cheese and nuts, it also adds calories and fat that a sprinkle of dried herbs does not, plus some salt. That is fine in most dishes, but cut back on the oil and Parmesan in the recipe a little. Add it near the end; long cooking dulls the basil and can make the oil separate.

What About the Health Side?

Italian seasoning is used by the teaspoon, so swapping it does not change a dish's nutrition much. Two points are still worth knowing.

  • Watch the salt in blends: Plain dried herbs, including standard Italian seasoning, have almost no sodium. Seasoning mixes are a different story: Greek seasoning, many pizza seasonings and za'atar blends often include salt, and Italian dressing mix packets are mostly salt. Building your own blend from single herbs keeps you in control.
  • Herbs help you use less salt: A dish full of herbs, garlic and acid tastes complete with less salt. In a 20-week randomized trial summarized by Harvard's Nutrition Source, 40 adults who were coached to cook with spices and herbs in place of salt ended up excreting about 957 mg less sodium per day than a self-directed control group. It was a small study, but it is a practical reason to be generous with herbs.

Fresh herbs also add to the variety of plants you eat, which is the idea behind the "30 plants a week" approach to gut health. Herbs count only for a small amount, but they are an easy way to add variety; our post on simple ways to sneak more plants into any meal has more ideas. As for health claims about individual herbs, like oregano's antioxidants, the evidence at kitchen quantities is thinner than social media suggests. Is Your Spice Rack a Medicine Cabinet? walks through what holds up.

What Not to Use

  • Italian dressing mix packets: They taste like Italian seasoning, but salt and sugar are usually the main ingredients. A teaspoon can easily over-salt a sauce.
  • Dried rosemary or sage at full strength: Either one alone, measured 1:1, will dominate the dish. Use a quarter of the amount, or mix with milder herbs.
  • Cajun or Creole seasoning: It has some thyme and oregano, but paprika, cayenne and garlic take over and push the dish somewhere else entirely, and many versions are heavily salted.
  • Dried parsley alone: It is mild to the point of tasting like almost nothing once dried. It adds color but very little flavor. Use it to stretch other herbs, not on its own.
  • Ground sage or ground thyme measured like leaves: Ground herbs pack more densely than dried leaves. If you only have ground, use about half the amount.

Which Italian Seasoning Substitute Should You Use?

If you have oregano, basil and a couple of other dried herbs, mix the homemade blend; it takes two minutes and you get to control the balance. If you only have oregano and basil, use equal parts and you will cover nearly every tomato sauce, soup and pasta dish. For roast chicken and vegetables, thyme, herbes de Provence, or Greek or poultry seasoning will do the job well. For dressings and garlic bread, reach for fresh herbs or a spoonful of pesto. And with any store-bought blend, check the label for salt before you season the rest of the dish.

If you are not sure which option fits the recipe on your stove, ask Eat Well Planner's AI recipe chat something like "I'm out of Italian seasoning, what should I use in this?" It answers with your actual recipe in context, including the herbs and salt already in it and when they go in. And if the dish is a family favorite like lasagna or spaghetti and meatballs, Make It Healthier suggests ingredient swaps and checks each one against the nutrition score before showing it to you. Our healthier spaghetti and meatballs and healthier lasagna makeovers show what those swaps look like in practice.

Weekly Tips, Free Forever

Eat Better Without
Overthinking It

More pantry rescues like this — plus gut-friendly recipes and meal plans packed with fresh herbs and flavor.