All Substitution Guides

8 Substitutes for Pumpkin Puree (for Pie, Muffins, Breads, and Soups)

Substitution Guide
8 Substitutes for Pumpkin Puree (for Pie, Muffins, Breads, and Soups)

The muffin batter is half mixed, the spices are measured, and the can of pumpkin you were sure was in the pantry turns out to be a can of black beans. Or it's October, and the store shelf where the pumpkin should be is bare again. Either way, you have more options than you'd think, because the pumpkin in that can is a dense, mildly sweet, orange winter squash puree. Plenty of other things in your kitchen can do the same job.

Pumpkin puree does three things in a recipe: it adds moisture and a soft, tender crumb to baked goods, it gives body to pie custards, soups and sauces, and it brings that earthy-sweet flavor and orange color. Which substitute works best depends on which of those jobs your recipe cares about most. A pumpkin pie needs a thick, smooth puree that sets into custard. A batch of muffins mostly needs moisture. A pumpkin soup or pasta sauce needs something savory-friendly, which rules out half the list.

Every swap below is measured against one standard 15-ounce can of pumpkin, which holds about 1 3/4 cups. Most of them go in cup for cup. The details that matter, like when to drain, how to adjust the sugar and what to skip, are in each section, followed by a guide to which substitute fits which recipe.

The Quick List

  • Butternut squash puree — the closest match for everything, including pie
  • Homemade pumpkin puree — the real thing, as long as you use a pie pumpkin
  • Other winter squash (kabocha, buttercup, honeynut, acorn) — great stand-ins, with a few texture caveats
  • Sweet potato puree — sweeter and richer, excellent in pie and baking
  • Carrot puree — keeps the orange color; best in muffins, breads and soups
  • Pumpkin pie mix — works in sweet baking if you cut the sugar and spices
  • Mashed ripe banana — moist, sweet, and good in muffins, breads and pancakes
  • Unsweetened applesauce — the mildest swap for cakes and quick breads

First: Pumpkin Puree vs. Pumpkin Pie Filling

These two cans sit side by side on the shelf, and they're easy to grab by mistake. Pumpkin puree (sometimes labeled "100% pure pumpkin") is just cooked, mashed pumpkin. Pumpkin pie mix or pumpkin pie filling is pumpkin with sugar, salt and spices already added. Libby's Easy Pumpkin Pie Mix, for example, lists pumpkin, water, sugar, salt, spices, dextrose and natural flavors, with 16 g of added sugar per 1/3 cup. As Chowhound puts it, the two are not interchangeable, and recipes always call for one or the other specifically.

If your recipe calls for pie filling and you only have puree, you can turn the puree into filling. The classic Libby's pie recipe, printed on the can for decades, seasons one 15-ounce can of puree with 3/4 cup sugar, 1/2 teaspoon salt, 1 teaspoon cinnamon, 1/2 teaspoon ginger and 1/4 teaspoon cloves. Going the other direction, from pie mix to a recipe that wants plain puree, is trickier. It's covered in the pie mix section below.

Butternut Squash Puree

  • Swap: 1 cup pumpkin puree → 1 cup butternut squash puree (about 1 3/4 cups replaces a 15-ounce can)
  • Best for: Everything: pumpkin pie, muffins, breads, pancakes, soups, curries, pasta sauces, risotto
  • Skip it for: Nothing, really; it only takes longer than opening a can
  • Health notes: A cup of baked butternut has 82 calories, 6.6 g fiber and 1,144 mcg of vitamin A, nearly identical to canned pumpkin on calories and fiber

Here's the fun fact that makes this the top pick: the pumpkin in most American cans is already very close to butternut squash. Libby's, which by one estimate grows about 85 percent of the country's canned pumpkin, uses its own Dickinson variety, and Dickinson belongs to Cucurbita moschata, the same squash species as butternut. It's tan-skinned and oblong, and it looks a lot more like a giant butternut than a jack-o'-lantern. So when you swap in butternut, you're staying in the same family. Tasting Table's pick for the absolute best substitute for pumpkin is butternut or its small, sweet cousin honeynut, used in exactly the same amount.

To make it, halve the squash lengthwise, scoop out the seeds, and roast it cut-side down on a lined sheet at 400°F until a knife slides in with no resistance, usually 40 to 60 minutes depending on size. Scoop the flesh into a food processor or blender and puree until completely smooth. Homemade squash puree is usually looser than canned pumpkin, so check it: it should hold a soft mound on a spoon. If it slumps, let it drain in a sieve lined with a paper towel or cheesecloth for 30 minutes to an hour, which matters most for pie. In a hurry? Steam peeled, cubed butternut (fresh or frozen) until very tender, then blend. Jarred butternut squash baby food also works in a pinch, though it's thinner than canned pumpkin and best kept to muffins and quick breads.

Expect a slightly lighter orange color and a sweeter, milder flavor than canned pumpkin. In a spiced pie or muffin, almost nobody will notice the difference.

Homemade Pumpkin Puree

  • Swap: 1 cup canned puree → 1 cup homemade puree, drained to a similar thickness
  • Best for: Pie, baking, soups, and anything where you want pumpkin flavor specifically
  • Skip it for: Nights when you need it in 15 minutes; roasting and draining take over an hour
  • Health notes: Same food as the can, minus any processing, and you get the seeds to roast

Make it from a pie pumpkin (also sold as a sugar pumpkin): the small, round, 2- to 4-pound kind, with dense flesh. Large carving pumpkins are bred for size and thin walls, and their flesh is watery, stringy and bland. A 3-pound pie pumpkin typically yields around 2 cups of puree, slightly more than one can.

Use the same method as butternut. Halve, seed, roast cut-side down at 400°F until very tender, then scoop and blend. Fresh pumpkin puree is noticeably wetter and paler than canned, so draining it in a lined sieve for 30 to 60 minutes isn't optional for pie. A watery puree gives you a pie that weeps and sets soft. Extra puree freezes well in 1 3/4-cup portions (one can's worth), so you can make it once and bake all season. One safety note: don't home-can it. The National Center for Home Food Preservation states that home canning is not recommended for mashed or pureed pumpkin or winter squash, and that pureed pumpkin can be frozen for long-term storage instead.

Other Winter Squash (Kabocha, Buttercup, Honeynut, Acorn)

  • Swap: 1 cup pumpkin puree → 1 cup winter squash puree
  • Best for: Kabocha and buttercup in pie and baking; any of them in soups, curries and muffins
  • Skip it for: Acorn and delicata in pie, unless you drain them well; they're wetter and milder
  • Health notes: Like pumpkin, these orange-fleshed squashes are good sources of fiber and beta-carotene

Most dense, orange-fleshed winter squashes make a perfectly good pumpkin stand-in. Kabocha and buttercup are the standouts. Their flesh is drier, denser and sweeter than pumpkin, with a chestnut-like flavor, and they make a silky pie. Because they're drier, they rarely need draining and may even need a tablespoon or two of water to blend smoothly. Honeynut is essentially a small, extra-sweet butternut, so treat it the same way.

Acorn and delicata are milder and more watery, with a slightly fibrous texture. They're fine in muffins, soups and curries, but for pie you'll want to blend them very smoothly and drain them well. Spaghetti squash doesn't work at all, since it cooks into strands rather than a puree.

Sweet Potato Puree

  • Swap: 1 cup pumpkin puree → 1 cup mashed sweet potato (roasted and blended, or canned and drained)
  • Best for: Pie, muffins, breads, pancakes, soups, curries
  • Skip it for: Recipes where you want a light, mild squash flavor; sweet potato is richer and sweeter
  • Health notes: A cup of canned mashed sweet potato has 232 calories, 4.6 g fiber, 1,017 mcg vitamin A and 796 mg potassium; that's still very nutritious, but nearly three times the calories of pumpkin

If you've ever had a Southern sweet potato pie, you already know this swap works: it's essentially pumpkin pie made with sweet potato, using the same custard. Sweet potato puree is a little thicker and sweeter than canned pumpkin and has a deeper, almost caramel flavor, especially if you roast the sweet potatoes in their skins rather than boiling them. Roast whole at 400°F until they're very soft and their sugars are oozing, about 45 to 60 minutes, then scoop out the flesh and blend until completely smooth. Because sweet potato is sweeter, taste the filling or batter before adding all the sugar.

For a shortcut, canned sweet potatoes work well. Look for plain, vacuum-packed or water-packed sweet potatoes, drain them, and blend. Avoid the "candied yams" packed in heavy syrup unless you rinse them well and cut the sugar elsewhere in the recipe. For a deeper look at a sweet potato dish rebuilt for nutrition, see our healthier sweet potato casserole.

Carrot Puree

  • Swap: 1 cup pumpkin puree → 1 cup smooth carrot puree
  • Best for: Muffins, quick breads, pancakes, soups, pasta sauces
  • Skip it for: A classic pumpkin pie if the pumpkin flavor is the point; carrot is more vegetal
  • Health notes: Carrots are one of the richest sources of beta-carotene, so the vitamin A stays high

Carrot puree keeps the bright orange color and the moist crumb, which is why it's the sleeper hit of this list. Peel and slice carrots, then boil or steam them until they're very soft, about 15 to 20 minutes. Blend them with just enough of the cooking water to get a smooth, thick puree. Roasting instead of boiling gives a sweeter, deeper flavor and a drier puree. Jarred carrot baby food is the fastest version: about four 4-ounce jars replace one 15-ounce can, though it's looser than canned pumpkin, so use it in muffins and breads rather than pie.

Carrot is less sweet than pumpkin and has a more vegetable-forward flavor. Spiced muffins and breads taste a bit like carrot cake, which is not a bad thing. In soups and pasta sauces, it's lovely with ginger, cumin or a splash of orange juice. If you want to make a pie with it, do half carrot and half sweet potato for a better flavor balance.

Pumpkin Pie Mix

  • Swap: 1 cup pumpkin puree → 1 cup pumpkin pie mix, then reduce the recipe's sugar by about 1/4 cup and leave out most of its warm spices
  • Best for: Muffins, quick breads, pancakes, pumpkin bars
  • Skip it for: Anything savory (soup, curry, pasta), and from-scratch pie recipes that already add sugar and spices
  • Health notes: A cup carries about 48 g of added sugar and only about 3 g of fiber, versus 7 g of fiber in a cup of plain pumpkin

If the only orange can you have is pie mix, it'll work in sweet baking with a couple of adjustments. The label lists 16 g of added sugar and 1 g of fiber per 1/3 cup. That works out to about 48 g of added sugar per cup, roughly 1/4 cup of granulated sugar. Cut the recipe's sugar by that much for each cup of mix you use, and halve or skip the recipe's cinnamon, ginger and cloves, since the mix brings its own. Water is the second ingredient on the label, so the mix is wetter than plain puree, and your batter may be a little looser. That's fine in muffins and quick breads, but check for doneness a few minutes later than the recipe says.

For pumpkin pie, don't try to adapt a from-scratch recipe. Just follow the instructions on the can, which are written for the mix: you only add eggs and evaporated milk. Our evaporated milk guide can help if you're out of that, too.

Mashed Ripe Banana

  • Swap: 1 cup pumpkin puree → 1 cup well-mashed very ripe banana (about 2 medium bananas)
  • Best for: Muffins, quick breads, pancakes, waffles, oatmeal, smoothies
  • Skip it for: Pumpkin pie, soups and anything savory
  • Health notes: A cup of mashed banana has 200 calories, 5.9 g fiber and 806 mg potassium, but about 28 g of sugar, compared to roughly 8 g in a cup of pumpkin

In muffins and quick breads, the pumpkin is mostly there for moisture and a tender crumb, and banana does both of those jobs very well. Use bananas that are heavily speckled or even fully brown. They mash smoothly and taste sweetest. Since banana is much sweeter than pumpkin, cut the recipe's sugar a little and taste the batter before it goes in the pan.

The trade-off is flavor. Your pumpkin bread will be a spiced banana bread, and there's no hiding it. Lean into it with cinnamon, nutmeg, walnuts or chocolate chips. Banana batters also brown faster in the oven because of their sugar, so check a few minutes early and tent with foil if the top darkens before the center is done. If you'd like to see how far a banana loaf can be pushed toward better nutrition, our healthier banana bread scores every swap.

Unsweetened Applesauce

  • Swap: 1 cup pumpkin puree → 1 cup thick, unsweetened applesauce
  • Best for: Spice cakes, muffins, quick breads, snack cakes
  • Skip it for: Pie, soups and savory dishes; it's too thin to set a custard and too fruity for savory food
  • Health notes: A cup of unsweetened applesauce has 102 calories, 2.7 g fiber and 23 g of sugar, with almost no vitamin A

Applesauce is the most neutral fruit swap on the list. It keeps baked goods moist and tender, and its flavor fades behind warm spices more easily than banana does. It's thinner than pumpkin, though. If yours is runny, let it drain in a fine sieve for 15 minutes, or reach for a chunkier "homestyle" sauce and blend it. Use unsweetened, or you're adding sugar on top of the sugar the recipe already calls for.

You will lose the orange color, and the result tastes more like an apple spice cake than pumpkin bread. It's a good save for a cake or muffin, but not one to reach for when pumpkin is the point.

Which Substitute for Which Recipe

Most of these work in most baked goods, but pie and savory dishes are pickier. Here's how to choose.

Pumpkin pie and custards

A pie needs a thick, smooth puree that sets when baked with eggs and milk. Your best choices, in order, are butternut squash, homemade pumpkin from a pie pumpkin, kabocha or buttercup, and sweet potato. Blend whichever you choose until it's completely smooth, and drain it until it holds a mound on a spoon. Too much moisture is the main reason a substitute pie cracks, weeps or sets soft. Skip banana and applesauce. They won't set properly, and they won't taste like pumpkin pie. If you're making pie from scratch anyway, our healthier pumpkin pie shows that the pumpkin filling was never the nutritional problem. The crust and the sugar were.

Muffins, quick breads, pancakes and bars

This is the most forgiving category. Here the pumpkin mostly adds moisture and tenderness, so every substitute on the list works. Squash, sweet potato and carrot keep the color and the "pumpkin bread" feel. Banana and applesauce work just as well texturally, but change the flavor. Pie mix works if you cut the sugar and spices.

Soups, curries, pasta sauces and risotto

Savory dishes need a savory-friendly vegetable. Butternut squash is the best match, followed by other winter squash, sweet potato and carrot. A blend of carrot and sweet potato is very convincing in a creamy soup. Never use pie mix, banana or applesauce here. Pie mix is sweetened and spiced, and the fruit swaps taste like dessert.

Oatmeal, smoothies and yogurt bowls

Anything goes. Butternut, sweet potato and banana are all great stirred into oats with cinnamon. Leftover squash or sweet potato puree freezes well in ice cube trays for exactly this use.

How the Substitutes Compare Nutritionally

Plain canned pumpkin is one of the most nutrient-dense things in the pantry. A cup has 83 calories, 7.1 g of fiber and 1,906 mcg of vitamin A, more than twice the 900 mcg Daily Value, plus 505 mg of potassium. So the question isn't which substitute is healthier than pumpkin. It's which ones keep what pumpkin gives you. Per cup:

  • Canned pumpkin: 83 calories, 7.1 g fiber, 8 g sugar, 1,906 mcg vitamin A
  • Butternut squash (baked, cubed): 82 calories, 6.6 g fiber, 4 g sugar, 1,144 mcg vitamin A
  • Sweet potato (canned, mashed): 232 calories, 4.6 g fiber, 13 g sugar, 1,017 mcg vitamin A
  • Mashed banana: 200 calories, 5.9 g fiber, 28 g sugar, very little vitamin A
  • Unsweetened applesauce: 102 calories, 2.7 g fiber, 23 g sugar, almost no vitamin A
  • Pumpkin pie mix: about 240 calories, 3 g fiber and 48 g added sugar (scaled up from the 1/3-cup label serving)

The pattern is clear. The orange vegetables (squash, sweet potato and carrot) keep the fiber and vitamin A, and butternut matches pumpkin almost exactly. The fruit swaps work beautifully in baking, but they trade some fiber and nearly all the vitamin A for more sugar. And pie mix is closer to a sweetened ingredient than a vegetable. None of that makes banana or applesauce a bad choice for a batch of muffins. It just means that if you're baking pumpkin bread partly for the pumpkin, reach for squash first. Every one of these is still a plant, too, so they all count toward a weekly plant-diversity goal.

This is the kind of trade-off that's hard to eyeball across a whole recipe. Eat Well Planner's Recipe Playground lets you swap the pumpkin for sweet potato or banana and watch the recipe's nutrition score, fiber and sugar change live before you bake anything. Make It Healthier goes one step further, suggesting swaps on its own and verifying the actual nutritional gain before showing them to you.

Take the Guesswork Out of Eating Well

Eat Well Planner helps you organize your favorite recipes, plan balanced meals, and automatically generate shopping lists — all in one place. Whether you're tracking macros, managing dietary restrictions, or just trying to stop asking "what's for dinner?", we've got you covered.

Our AI-powered tools can adapt any recipe to your dietary needs, help you discover new meals you'll love, and even log your nutrition effortlessly. It's meal planning made simple.

Start Organizing Your Meals — Free

What Not to Use

  • A carving pumpkin. Jack-o'-lantern pumpkins are bred to be big and hollow, not to be eaten. Their flesh is watery, stringy and bland, and makes a thin, flavorless puree. Use a pie pumpkin or butternut instead.
  • Pumpkin pie mix in anything savory. It's already sweetened and spiced, so a soup or pasta sauce made with it tastes like dessert. There's no fixing that after the fact.
  • Pumpkin soup or canned squash soup. It's far too thin to replace puree, and it's seasoned with salt, onion and often cream.
  • Pumpkin butter. It's cooked down with plenty of sugar and spice, so it behaves like a jam, not a puree. Save it for toast.
  • Raw grated pumpkin or squash. Shredded raw squash releases water as it bakes and doesn't give the smooth, dense texture that puree does. Recipes written for grated squash are different recipes.
  • Unblended, lumpy mash. Any substitute needs to be blended completely smooth, especially for pie. Fork-mashed squash or sweet potato leaves fibrous streaks in a custard.

Make Any of These Fit Your Recipe

Pumpkin puree is one of the easier ingredients to replace, because most of what it does comes from being a thick, sweet, orange vegetable puree, and you can make that from several things. Butternut squash is the all-around winner, and it's practically what's in the can anyway. Homemade pie-pumpkin puree, kabocha and sweet potato are excellent for pie as long as you drain them well. Carrot keeps the color and the nutrition in muffins and soups, and banana, applesauce or pie mix will save a batch of muffins in a pinch.

Not sure which one suits the recipe in front of you? Open it in Eat Well Planner and ask the AI recipe chat something like "I'm out of pumpkin puree, what should I use?" It'll recommend a swap for that specific dish, with the full recipe in context. It can even tell you how much to cut the sugar if you're using banana or pie mix. And if you'd rather have the change worked into the whole recipe, Recipe Variations will rewrite it for you, with every amount adjusted.

Weekly Tips, Free Forever

Eat Better Without
Overthinking It

More kitchen saves like these — plus gut-friendly recipes and meal plans for fall baking and beyond.