All Substitution Guides

8 Substitutes for Sun-Dried Tomatoes (for Pasta, Salads, Pesto, and Pizza)

Substitution Guide
8 Substitutes for Sun-Dried Tomatoes (for Pasta, Salads, Pesto, and Pizza)

The pasta water is boiling, the garlic is in the pan, and the recipe wants "1/2 cup sun-dried tomatoes, chopped." The jar in the fridge door turns out to be olive oil and two lonely tomato halves stuck to the glass. Or you never bought any, because who keeps sun-dried tomatoes on hand?

Sun-dried tomatoes are a concentrated ingredient. Drying strips out most of the water, so what is left is intensely sweet, tangy, and savory, with a dense, chewy texture that no fresh tomato has. A good substitute has to bring some of that concentration. The best ones also bring a bit of chew, or at least do not flood the dish with juice.

The right pick depends on what you are making. In a creamy pasta sauce, you mostly need the deep tomato flavor, so a pantry swap like tomato paste is fine. In a salad or grain bowl, you need something you can see and bite, which points to roasted tomatoes or roasted red peppers. And in pesto or a spread, color and body matter as much as taste. Below are the substitutes that actually work, with exact ratios, followed by a pick-by-dish guide and a section on swapping oil-packed and dry-packed tomatoes for each other.

The Quick List

  • Oven-dried tomatoes — the real thing, made at home; a 1:1 swap anywhere, but it takes a couple of hours
  • Roasted cherry tomatoes — the fast version; sweet, jammy, and on the table in 25 minutes
  • Semi-dried (sun-blushed) tomatoes — softer and milder; a ready-made 1:1 swap from the deli counter
  • Roasted red peppers — the best jarred stand-in for pesto, spreads, sandwiches, and salads
  • Tomato paste plus olive oil — the pantry pick for pasta sauces, cream sauces, soups, and stews
  • Canned tomatoes, cooked down — for long-simmered sauces, braises, and soups
  • Chopped Kalamata olives — salty, chewy punch for salads, grain bowls, and Mediterranean pasta
  • Dry-packed or oil-packed sun-dried tomatoes — if you have the "wrong" kind, here is how to swap one for the other

Oven-Dried Tomatoes

  • Swap: 1:1 with oil-packed sun-dried tomatoes; about 1 pound of fresh Roma tomatoes makes 1 cup
  • Best for: Everything — pasta, salads, pesto, pizza, focaccia, sandwiches, and antipasto
  • Skip it for: Tonight's dinner if it is already 6 p.m.; the oven needs 2 to 3 hours

Commercial sun-dried tomatoes are just tomatoes with most of their water removed, and a low oven does the same job as the sun. Sunset's method is a good one to follow: slice 1 pound of firm-ripe Roma tomatoes into 1/4-inch rounds, pat them dry, lay them on an oiled pan, sprinkle lightly with salt and pepper, and bake at 200°F for 2 1/4 to 2 3/4 hours, until they are dry but still pliable. The batch makes about a cup.

Roma (plum) tomatoes are the right choice because they are meaty and have fewer seeds and less juice than round slicing tomatoes. Thin rounds dry fastest; halves take much longer and stay juicier in the middle, which is closer to the semi-dried style below. Store them airtight in the refrigerator; Sunset says they keep for up to 3 days. If you want them to last longer, cover them in olive oil and keep them in the fridge, the same way America's Test Kitchen stores rehydrated sun-dried tomatoes: under oil, refrigerated, for up to 2 weeks. Never leave tomatoes in oil at room temperature.

Roasted Cherry Tomatoes

  • Swap: 1/4 cup chopped sun-dried tomatoes → about 1/2 cup roasted cherry or grape tomatoes (from roughly 1 cup raw)
  • Best for: Pasta, grain bowls, warm salads, flatbreads, bruschetta, and anything topped with feta or goat cheese
  • Skip it for: Pesto, spreads, and bread doughs, where the extra juice throws off the texture

This is the swap for when you need something tonight. Halve 1 cup of cherry or grape tomatoes, toss them with 1 teaspoon of olive oil and a pinch of salt, spread them cut side up on a sheet pan, and roast at 425°F for 20 to 25 minutes, until they collapse and the edges brown. Cherry tomatoes are naturally sweet, and the high heat concentrates that sweetness into something close to sun-dried flavor.

They are juicier and softer than the real thing, and their flavor is less intense, which is why the ratio calls for about twice the volume. In a pasta, that juice is a bonus: it mixes with the olive oil and starchy pasta water into a light sauce. Scrape every bit of the caramelized juice off the pan. If you are making a goat cheese or feta salad and also need a swap for the cheese, our goat cheese substitutes guide pairs nicely with this one.

Semi-Dried (Sun-Blushed) Tomatoes

  • Swap: 1:1 with sun-dried tomatoes, chopped
  • Best for: Salads, sandwiches, antipasto, pasta, pizza
  • Skip it for: Recipes that rely on sun-dried tomatoes' chew, like some breads and stuffings

Semi-dried tomatoes, often labeled "sun-blushed" or "sun-kissed," are dried only partway and usually sold in oil at deli counters and olive bars. Greedy Gourmet notes that they retain a lot more moisture, so they are softer, a little sweeter, and less intense than fully dried tomatoes, and it recommends swapping them like for like.

Since they are the same ingredient at a different stage, they are the most faithful store-bought swap. They are plumper and juicier, so in a cream sauce you may want a few extra pieces, and in a salad they read as a treat rather than a compromise. Drain them well before using, and save the oil for cooking.

Roasted Red Peppers

  • Swap: 1/4 cup chopped sun-dried tomatoes → 1/4 cup chopped jarred roasted red peppers, patted very dry, plus 1/4 teaspoon balsamic vinegar or a squeeze of lemon and a pinch of salt
  • Best for: Pesto, hummus, dips, spreads, sandwiches, wraps, salads, pasta salads, and pizza
  • Skip it for: Long-simmered tomato sauces, where the pepper flavor takes over
  • Health notes: A different plant from tomato, so it adds variety, and canned sweet red peppers still carry about 46 mg of vitamin C per 100 grams

Roasted red peppers share the deep red color, the gentle sweetness, and the smoky edge of sun-dried tomatoes, which makes them the best substitute in dishes where color and texture matter. Greedy Gourmet recommends a like-for-like swap and suggests adding olive oil, salt, garlic, or lemon to boost the flavor.

The trick is moisture. Jarred peppers are packed in brine, so blot them hard on paper towels before chopping, especially for pesto or a spread, or it will turn loose and watery. What they lack is tang, which is where the balsamic or lemon comes in. A red pepper pesto made this way is not a sun-dried tomato pesto, but it is a delicious red pesto in its own right. Piquillo peppers are an even better match if you can find them: smaller, sweeter, and slightly smoky. If you are out of balsamic too, our balsamic vinegar substitutes guide has options.

Tomato Paste Plus Olive Oil

  • Swap: 1/4 cup chopped sun-dried tomatoes (4 to 5 pieces) → 1 tablespoon tomato paste cooked in 1 teaspoon olive oil until it darkens to brick red
  • Best for: Creamy pasta sauces (like Tuscan or "marry me" chicken), tomato soups, stews, chili, and braises
  • Skip it for: Salads, toppings, and anywhere the tomatoes need to be seen or chewed

Tomato paste is the closest thing in your pantry to sun-dried tomato flavor. It is made by cooking tomatoes down until most of their water is gone, so it has the same concentrated sweetness and savory depth. Greedy Gourmet's guideline is 1 tablespoon of paste for every 4 to 5 sun-dried tomatoes, and it notes that paste does not add extra liquid, so you will not need to adjust anything else.

The step that makes it work is frying the paste in the oil for a minute or two before the liquids go in. That cooks off the raw, tinny edge and deepens the color and sweetness, much like the caramelized notes of dried tomatoes. In a cream sauce, the result is almost identical in taste; what you lose is the chewy little bits. To get some of that back, add a few chopped roasted red peppers or olives. Our tomato paste substitutes guide covers the reverse situation, if the paste is what you are missing.

Canned Tomatoes, Cooked Down

  • Swap: 1/4 cup chopped sun-dried tomatoes → 3/4 cup canned diced tomatoes, simmered until reduced by about half
  • Best for: Pasta sauces, soups, stews, shakshuka, and braises
  • Skip it for: Salads, pesto, spreads, and breads

Canned tomatoes have the right flavor family but far too much water, so they need time in the pan. Greedy Gourmet suggests using 3/4 cup canned tomatoes for every 1/4 cup sun-dried tomatoes. Simmer them on their own for about 10 minutes, or until they reduce by half and start to stick to the pan, before adding the rest of the sauce. A teaspoon of tomato paste stirred in at the same time pushes the flavor closer to sun-dried.

Fire-roasted canned tomatoes are the better choice if you have them, since their smoky, charred notes mimic the dried flavor. This is not a quick swap, but in a sauce that simmers for half an hour anyway, it disappears into the dish.

Chopped Kalamata Olives

  • Swap: 1/4 cup chopped sun-dried tomatoes → 2 tablespoons chopped Kalamata olives; for the sweetness, add 2 tablespoons chopped roasted red pepper
  • Best for: Greek and Mediterranean salads, orzo and couscous salads, grain bowls, pasta, focaccia, tapenade
  • Skip it for: Cream sauces and tomato soups, where olives add salt but none of the tomato flavor

Olives do not taste like tomatoes, but they fill the same role in many Mediterranean dishes: a salty, savory, chewy bite scattered through a salad or pasta. Kalamatas are the best choice here, with a fruity, winey flavor and a deep purple color that looks right next to feta and greens.

Use half the amount, since olives are saltier and stronger. Then go easy on any other salt in the recipe. What olives cannot bring is sweetness, which is why the roasted pepper combo is the best version of this swap: the olives handle the salty punch, and the peppers handle the sweet. If you are out of feta for the same salad, see our feta cheese substitutes.

Oil-Packed vs. Dry-Packed: Swapping One for the Other

Sometimes the problem is not that you have no sun-dried tomatoes, but that you have the wrong kind. Most recipes assume oil-packed tomatoes, which are soft and ready to use. Dry-packed tomatoes, sold in bags, are leathery and need rehydrating first. They are interchangeable piece for piece once prepped.

Using Dry-Packed in Place of Oil-Packed

  • Swap: 1 rehydrated dry-packed tomato = 1 oil-packed tomato; 1/2 cup dry-packed makes enough for most recipes calling for 1/2 cup oil-packed
  • Best for: Everything, once rehydrated
  • Skip it for: Nothing, but do not skip the soak in salads or sandwiches

America's Test Kitchen tested the options and found that plain water left the tomatoes waterlogged and diluted their flavor, wine overpowered them, and an overnight soak in olive oil left them too tough. Broth worked best. Their method: put 1/2 cup dry-packed tomatoes in a heatproof bowl with 1 cup of broth, or 1 cup warm water with 1/2 teaspoon salt dissolved in it. Cover with a plate, microwave for 2 minutes, and let them sit for 5 to 10 minutes, until the skin side pierces easily with a fork. Drain and blot well.

If the tomatoes are going into a soup, stew, or long-simmered sauce, you can skip the soak entirely and add them dry; they will soften in the liquid. To get the richness of oil-packed tomatoes in a salad or pasta, toss the rehydrated pieces with a teaspoon or two of olive oil.

Using Oil-Packed in Place of Dry-Packed

  • Swap: 1 oil-packed tomato = 1 dry-packed tomato; skip any soaking step in the recipe
  • Best for: Everything except recipes that grind dry tomatoes into a powder or seasoning
  • Skip it for: Dry rubs and spice blends

Drain them well and pat off the surface oil, especially for bread doughs, where extra fat can affect the crumb. Then reduce the oil elsewhere in the recipe by a teaspoon or two. Do not throw away the jar oil: it is infused with tomato and herb flavor and makes a great base for sautéing garlic, dressing a salad, or brushing on bread.

Which Substitute for Which Dish

Creamy Pasta and "Marry Me" Chicken

Tomato paste cooked in olive oil is the best flavor match, with a handful of roasted cherry tomatoes or chopped roasted red peppers stirred in at the end for texture. If you have them, semi-dried tomatoes are a 1:1 swap. For a dairy-free version of the sauce, our coconut milk substitutes guide covers the cream side.

Salads and Grain Bowls

Roasted cherry tomatoes for warm salads and bowls; semi-dried tomatoes or roasted red peppers for cold ones. Kalamata olives plus roasted red pepper is the best combo for Greek-style salads and orzo salads.

Sun-Dried Tomato Pesto, Dips, and Spreads

When sun-dried tomatoes are the star, no substitute gives you the same dish. Oven-dried tomatoes come closest if you have the time. Otherwise, make a roasted red pepper pesto with well-dried peppers and a splash of balsamic, plus 1 tablespoon of tomato paste for every cup of peppers to keep the tomato note. You will get a lighter, sweeter red pesto, not a copy.

Pizza, Flatbreads, and Sandwiches

Roasted red peppers or semi-dried tomatoes, 1:1. Roasted cherry tomatoes are great on flatbreads, but drain them first so the crust stays crisp.

Bread, Focaccia, and Savory Baking

Oven-dried tomatoes or well-drained semi-dried tomatoes. Chopped Kalamata olives are the best quick swap in focaccia. Avoid juicy substitutes like fresh or roasted cherry tomatoes inside a dough, since they add water and create soggy pockets.

Soups, Stews, and Braises

Tomato paste or canned tomatoes cooked down; both disappear into the dish. If you have dry-packed tomatoes, add them straight to the pot without soaking.

The Healthier Angle: Small Amounts, Big Nutrition

Sun-dried tomatoes are one of the most nutrient-dense ways to eat a tomato, simply because the water is gone. USDA data for dry-packed sun-dried tomatoes lists about 3,427 mg of potassium, 12.3 g of fiber, and 45.9 mg of lycopene per 100 grams. A quarter cup weighs only about 13.5 grams, but even that comes out to roughly 460 mg of potassium, 1.7 grams of fiber, and about 6 mg of lycopene, the red carotenoid tomatoes are known for, all for around 35 calories.

Oil-packed tomatoes are a little different. Drained, they carry about 234 calories and 15 grams of fat per cup, compared with about 139 calories for a cup of dry-packed. That is not a reason to avoid them — the oil is usually olive oil — but if you are watching calories, dry-packed and rehydrated tomatoes give you the same flavor for less. Check the label for sodium either way, since many brands of both kinds add salt.

The oil does serve a purpose, though. Lycopene is fat-soluble, and eating tomatoes with some fat helps you absorb it. In one study, adding avocado to salsa raised lycopene absorption to about 4.4 times that of the same salsa without it. Another found that eating tomato products with extra-virgin olive oil or sunflower oil raised blood lycopene levels similarly, but only the olive oil group saw a rise in the blood's antioxidant activity. So whichever substitute you choose, a drizzle of olive oil is worth keeping in the dish.

Among the substitutes, tomato paste and oven-dried or roasted tomatoes keep the most of the tomato's nutrition, since they are the same plant concentrated in different ways. Roasted red peppers trade the lycopene for a different nutrient profile and add a different plant to your week, which is a small win if you are aiming for more plant variety for gut health.

Take the Guesswork Out of Eating Well

Eat Well Planner helps you organize your favorite recipes, plan balanced meals, and automatically generate shopping lists — all in one place. Whether you're tracking macros, managing dietary restrictions, or just trying to stop asking "what's for dinner?", we've got you covered.

Our AI-powered tools can adapt any recipe to your dietary needs, help you discover new meals you'll love, and even log your nutrition effortlessly. It's meal planning made simple.

Start Organizing Your Meals — Free

What Not to Use

  • Raw fresh tomatoes, straight in. Chopped fresh tomatoes are mostly water. In a pasta sauce they thin it out; in a pesto, bread, or sandwich, they make it soggy. Roast them first, or use the canned-and-reduced method.
  • Ketchup. It brings tomato flavor, but also sugar and vinegar in amounts that make a cream sauce or pasta taste like a burger condiment.
  • Dried cranberries or other dried fruit. Some lists suggest them because they are chewy and sweet. In a salad they are fine on their own terms, but they add fruit sweetness with none of the savory, tangy depth that sun-dried tomatoes bring. They are a different salad, not a substitute.
  • Unsoaked dry-packed tomatoes in a salad or sandwich. They are tough, leathery, and hard to chew without rehydrating. Only add them dry to dishes with plenty of simmering liquid.
  • Leaving them out with nothing in their place. In a creamy pasta or a Mediterranean salad, sun-dried tomatoes are often the main source of sweetness and depth. Without them, the dish tastes flat. Even a spoonful of tomato paste or a handful of olives fixes that.

Not Sure Which One Fits Your Recipe?

This guide covers the general rules. What it cannot do is look at your recipe and say whether the sun-dried tomatoes are the backbone of the sauce or a garnish on top, and which swap makes sense with everything else in the dish.

That is what Eat Well Planner does. Import your recipe from any website, Instagram reel, or YouTube video, and its AI recipe chat can answer with the full ingredient list in front of it: which substitute fits, how much to use, and whether to adjust the oil, salt, or liquid. And if you are curious what a swap does to the nutrition, such as dry-packed tomatoes instead of oil-packed, or roasted peppers instead of olives, the Recipe Playground shows the change in the recipe's nutrition score as you make it, so you can decide before you cook.

Weekly Tips, Free Forever

Eat Better Without
Overthinking It

Weekly kitchen fixes — clever swaps, gut-friendly recipes, and meal plans built from real food.