The carrot cake batter is mixed, the jerk marinade is half blended, or the Swedish meatballs are waiting on one last spice, and the allspice jar is empty. It is an easy spice to run out of because most people only reach for it a few times a year, and an easy one to underestimate, because a single teaspoon does a lot of the work in the dishes that use it.
Here is the helpful part: allspice is one dried berry that happens to taste like a blend. The English named it in the 1600s because it reminded them of cinnamon, nutmeg and cloves all at once, according to its Wikipedia entry, which means you can rebuild it pretty convincingly from those three spices. That homemade blend is the best substitute for almost everything, so it comes first. The rest of the list covers what to use when you are missing one of the three, and how the answer changes between a spice cake and a pot of jerk chicken.
All ratios below assume the recipe calls for ground allspice. If you are replacing whole allspice berries in a pickle, brine or stew, skip to the whole-berries section.
The Quick List
- DIY blend (cinnamon + nutmeg + cloves) — the closest match, works in sweet and savory recipes alike
- Pumpkin pie spice — the easiest fix for pies, cakes, muffins and quick breads
- Mixed spice — the British baking blend, which already contains allspice
- Cinnamon + cloves — the two-spice version when you are out of nutmeg
- Ground cloves — the best single spice for savory dishes, at half the amount
- Ground nutmeg — a softer single-spice option for baking and cream sauces, at half the amount
- Cinnamon — the one everyone has, fine in sweet recipes
- Chinese five-spice — for braises, glazes and roasted meats, not delicate desserts
- Whole cloves + black peppercorns — the stand-in for whole allspice berries in pickles, brines and stews
Match the Substitute to the Dish
- Pumpkin pie, carrot cake, spice cake, gingerbread, muffins, quick breads — DIY blend, pumpkin pie spice, mixed spice, cinnamon + cloves
- Fruit pies, crumbles, baked apples, oatmeal — DIY blend, pumpkin pie spice, cinnamon
- Jerk chicken, jerk pork, Caribbean stews — DIY blend with black pepper added (see the jerk section below)
- Swedish meatballs, meatloaf, Cincinnati chili, Middle Eastern stews, tomato sauces — DIY blend, ground cloves, five-spice in small amounts
- Pickles, brines, pot roast, mulled cider or wine (whole berries) — whole cloves + black peppercorns
- Béchamel, creamed spinach, mashed squash — ground nutmeg
DIY Allspice Blend (Cinnamon + Nutmeg + Cloves)
- Swap: 1 teaspoon ground allspice → 1/2 teaspoon ground cinnamon + 1/4 teaspoon ground nutmeg + 1/4 teaspoon ground cloves
- Best for: Everything allspice goes in: baking, meatballs, chili, stews, marinades, jerk
- Skip it for: Nothing in particular; it is the first choice whenever you have all three spices
This is the standard homemade substitute, and the one most cooking references land on. Silver Spoon's baking guide gives the same proportions by weight: 10 g of allspice replaced with 5 g of cinnamon, 2.5 g of cloves and 2.5 g of nutmeg. Stir the three together in a small bowl before adding them so the cloves do not end up concentrated in one bite.
The blend tastes a little sweeter and less peppery than real allspice, because cinnamon is doing half the work. That is barely noticeable in a cake or pie. In savory dishes, where allspice's peppery edge matters more, swap a pinch of the cinnamon for a pinch of black pepper, or see the jerk section below. If you bake often, it is worth mixing a few tablespoons at once in the same 2:1:1 ratio and keeping it in a labeled jar.
Pumpkin Pie Spice
- Swap: 1 teaspoon ground allspice → 1 teaspoon pumpkin pie spice
- Best for: Pumpkin and sweet potato pie, carrot cake, spice cake, muffins, quick breads, oatmeal, spiced lattes
- Skip it for: Jerk, chili and meat dishes, where the ginger and extra cinnamon taste out of place
Pumpkin pie spice is typically cinnamon, ginger, nutmeg and cloves, and many blends include allspice too. It is already built to taste like the warm mix allspice gives a baked good, so it is the easiest 1:1 swap in sweet recipes. Check the jar's ingredient list; if allspice is in it, you are partway to the real thing.
One thing to watch: if your recipe already calls for cinnamon and ginger alongside the allspice, adding pumpkin pie spice tips the balance further toward those two. In that case, reduce the cinnamon in the recipe by about a quarter teaspoon and the result will taste closer to the original. If you are also out of the canned pumpkin for the pie, see our pumpkin puree substitutes.
Mixed Spice
- Swap: 1 teaspoon ground allspice → 1 teaspoon mixed spice
- Best for: Fruitcakes, hot cross buns, spice cakes, puddings, mince pies
- Skip it for: Jerk and other dishes where allspice is the main spice
Mixed spice is the British equivalent of pumpkin pie spice, and it is the reason a lot of people confuse the two names. Silver Spoon notes that mixed spice typically contains allspice, cinnamon, nutmeg, mace, cloves, coriander and ginger, so it already includes the spice you are trying to replace. It works 1:1 in both sweet and savory baking.
It is not common on American shelves, so this one mostly applies if you have a jar from a British recipe. If a British recipe calls for mixed spice and you have allspice instead, the swap works in the other direction too.
Cinnamon + Cloves
- Swap: 1 teaspoon ground allspice → 3/4 teaspoon ground cinnamon + 1/4 teaspoon ground cloves
- Best for: Baking, fruit desserts, meatballs, stews, when you have no nutmeg
- Skip it for: Nothing specific; it is just slightly less rounded than the three-spice blend
This is the DIY blend with the nutmeg portion folded into the cinnamon. Cloves carry most of what makes allspice taste like allspice (both get their warm, numbing bite from the same compound, eugenol), so keeping them at a quarter teaspoon preserves the character, while the cinnamon fills out the sweetness. Do not increase the cloves to make up for the missing nutmeg. Cloves are strong enough that an extra quarter teaspoon can turn a cake medicinal.
If you are out of nutmeg and allspice at the same time and have a nutmeg-heavy recipe on the go, our nutmeg substitutes guide covers that side of the problem.
Ground Cloves
- Swap: 1 teaspoon ground allspice → 1/2 teaspoon ground cloves (start with 1/4 teaspoon and taste)
- Best for: Meatballs, chili, stews, tomato sauces, gingerbread, mulled drinks
- Skip it for: Delicate cakes, custards and anything where a teaspoon of allspice is the only spice
On its own, clove is the spice that tastes most like allspice: warm, pungent and slightly numbing. It is also considerably stronger, which is why Silver Spoon gives the swap as 10 g of allspice to 5 g of cloves and recommends starting with less. In a savory dish with plenty of other flavors (tomato, onion, garlic, meat), half the amount is about right. In something mild, start at a quarter and add more only after tasting.
Cloves are a particularly good fit for Cincinnati-style chili, which owes its distinctive aroma to allspice and usually includes cloves already. Adding a little extra clove and an extra pinch of cinnamon keeps the flavor recognizable. If the chili powder ran out too, our chili powder substitutes cover the base of the pot.
Ground Nutmeg
- Swap: 1 teaspoon ground allspice → 1/2 teaspoon ground nutmeg
- Best for: Béchamel, creamed vegetables, mashed squash, custards, eggnog, mild baked goods
- Skip it for: Jerk and heavily spiced meat dishes, where it is too soft to carry the flavor
Nutmeg brings the sweet, rounded part of allspice's flavor without the clove bite. That makes it a weaker match in jerk or chili but a better one in pale, creamy dishes, where cloves would read as harsh. Silver Spoon recommends half the amount, since it is hard to fix too much nutmeg once something is in the oven.
Keep it to the half ratio. Nutmeg is perfectly safe in cooking amounts but becomes toxic in large doses, so there is never a reason to double it to make up for a weak substitute.
Cinnamon
- Swap: 1 teaspoon ground allspice → 1 teaspoon ground cinnamon (or 3/4 teaspoon if the recipe already has cinnamon)
- Best for: Sweet recipes: pies, crumbles, muffins, quick breads, oatmeal, baked fruit
- Skip it for: Savory marinades, jerk and meat dishes
Cinnamon alone is the substitute almost everyone has, and Silver Spoon puts it at 1:1. It works because cinnamon is a big part of what allspice tastes like, but it misses the peppery, clove-like depth, so the result is sweeter and flatter. In a fruit crumble or a batch of muffins where allspice is one of several spices, no one will notice. In a spice cake where allspice is the star, the cake will taste mostly of cinnamon.
If you have a single whole clove in the cabinet, crushing it and adding the powder to the cinnamon brings this much closer to the real thing.
Chinese Five-Spice
- Swap: 1 teaspoon ground allspice → 1/2 to 1 teaspoon Chinese five-spice powder
- Best for: Braised meats, glazed pork, roasted duck or chicken, barbecue rubs, spiced nuts
- Skip it for: Pumpkin pie, custards and delicate cakes, where the star anise stands out
Five-spice is usually star anise, cloves, cinnamon, Sichuan pepper and fennel. The cloves, cinnamon and pepper overlap neatly with allspice, but the star anise and fennel add a licorice note that allspice does not have. Silver Spoon lists it as a 1:1 swap. Start at half and taste in anything other than a rich, savory dish, because the anise note gets loud fast.
Where it shines is in the dishes allspice already shares with five-spice: sticky glazed pork, braised short ribs and roasted meats. It also works in gingerbread if you like a slightly darker, more aromatic spice profile.
Whole Allspice Berries: What to Use Instead
- Swap: For every 2 whole allspice berries, use 1 whole clove + 1 black peppercorn
- Best for: Pickles, brines, corned beef, pot roast, soups and stews, mulled cider and wine
- Skip it for: Recipes that grind the berries; use one of the ground substitutes above instead
Whole allspice berries look like large brown peppercorns, and they behave like them in cooking: they infuse a liquid slowly and are fished out or strained away before serving. Whole cloves give you the clove note at roughly half the count, and black peppercorns replace the peppery body. A small piece of cinnamon stick added to a brine or mulled wine rounds it out.
Going the other way: if you have whole berries and the recipe calls for ground, grind them in a spice or coffee grinder and measure after grinding. Freshly ground allspice is noticeably more potent than an old jar, so start with a little less than the recipe says and taste.
Substitutes for Allspice in Jerk Seasoning
Jerk is the one dish where allspice is not a background spice. In Jamaica it goes by the name pimento, and it is the backbone of the seasoning alongside Scotch bonnet peppers, thyme, scallions, garlic and ginger. Recipes often call for a tablespoon or more, so a weak substitute here leaves the whole dish tasting thin.
- Best option: the DIY blend plus black pepper. For each 1 teaspoon of allspice, use 1/2 teaspoon cinnamon, 1/4 teaspoon nutmeg, 1/4 teaspoon cloves and 1/4 teaspoon freshly ground black pepper. The pepper replaces the sharp, peppery side of real pimento that the sweet spices miss.
- Missing nutmeg? Use 1/2 teaspoon cinnamon, 1/4 teaspoon cloves and 1/4 teaspoon black pepper per teaspoon of allspice.
- Store-bought jerk seasoning. It contains allspice, so it can stand in for the allspice and the other dry spices in the recipe. Many blends are salt- and sugar-heavy, though, so check the label and cut back on any salt the recipe adds separately.
Do not use pumpkin pie spice or five-spice in jerk. The extra ginger and cinnamon in one and the star anise in the other pull the flavor away from what makes jerk taste like jerk. If you are short on Scotch bonnets too, habaneros are the closest stand-in for heat and fruity flavor.
Take the Guesswork Out of Eating Well
Eat Well Planner helps you organize your favorite recipes, plan balanced meals, and automatically generate shopping lists — all in one place. Whether you're tracking macros, managing dietary restrictions, or just trying to stop asking "what's for dinner?", we've got you covered.
Our AI-powered tools can adapt any recipe to your dietary needs, help you discover new meals you'll love, and even log your nutrition effortlessly. It's meal planning made simple.
Start Organizing Your Meals — FreeWhat About the Health Side?
Allspice and its substitutes are used in such small amounts that swapping one for another will not meaningfully change the nutrition of a dish. A few points are still worth knowing.
- Single spices are essentially salt-free. Cinnamon, nutmeg, cloves and allspice itself add flavor without sodium. Blends are where salt hides: many jerk seasonings and barbecue rubs include salt, sometimes a lot of it, so a tablespoon of blend can quietly add to the salt the recipe already measures out. The DIY blend avoids that entirely.
- Warm spices make it easier to cut sugar and salt. A spice like allspice makes food taste sweeter and richer than it is, which lets you use less sugar in oatmeal, muffins and fruit desserts without the result tasting flat. For savory food, the same idea applies to salt. In a 20-week randomized trial summarized by Harvard's Nutrition Source, 40 participants who learned to cook with spices and herbs instead of salt ended up eating about 957 mg less sodium per day than a control group. It was a small study, but the practical point holds.
- Treat big health claims with caution. Allspice, like cloves, is rich in eugenol, and you will see it credited with everything from fighting inflammation to easing digestion. Most of that research is in cell cultures, animals or concentrated extracts, not the teaspoon in a spice cake. For an honest look at which spice claims hold up, see Is Your Spice Rack a Medicine Cabinet?
A Healthier Use for Your Substitute
If you are reaching for an allspice substitute because you are baking, it is worth knowing that warm spices are one of the simplest ways to make a recipe a little better for you without anyone noticing. A generous teaspoon of the DIY blend in muffins, quick breads or baked oatmeal lets you cut back on the sugar without the result tasting bland. Our healthier pumpkin pie makeover uses the same trick: more spice, so the filling tastes sweeter than its sugar would suggest.
On the savory side, allspice is one of the quiet reasons Swedish meatballs taste the way they do, and the DIY blend works just as well there. Spiced meat dishes like these are also a good place to stretch the meat with lentils, mushrooms or grated vegetables, since the warm spices carry the flavor and make the swap easy to miss.
What Not to Use
- Equal amounts of cloves: Cloves are much stronger than allspice. A full teaspoon in place of a teaspoon of allspice can make a cake or a sauce taste bitter and medicinal. Stick to half or less.
- Doubling nutmeg to make up for a weak swap: It does not add the clove depth that is missing, and large amounts of nutmeg are genuinely unsafe.
- Garam masala in baking: It shares cinnamon and cloves with allspice, but most blends also include cumin, coriander and black pepper, which do not belong in a pie. It can work in a spiced stew or chili; see our garam masala guide for what is in it.
- Pumpkin pie spice or five-spice in jerk: Both change the flavor rather than filling in for the allspice. Use the DIY blend with black pepper.
- Pimento peppers or pimientos: Allspice is sometimes called "pimento" in Jamaican recipes, but the red jarred pimientos in olives are a mild sweet pepper and taste nothing like it.
- Ground ginger alone: Warm, but in a different direction. It works alongside cinnamon in baking, not as a stand-in for allspice by itself.
Which Allspice Substitute Should You Use?
If you have cinnamon, nutmeg and cloves, mix 1/2 teaspoon, 1/4 teaspoon and 1/4 teaspoon for each teaspoon of allspice and use it anywhere. For baking, pumpkin pie spice or mixed spice at the same amount is the next easiest fix. For savory dishes, use half the amount of ground cloves, or cinnamon plus cloves if you have both. For jerk, add black pepper to the DIY blend. And for whole berries in a pickle or a pot roast, use half as many whole cloves plus the same number of black peppercorns.
If you are not sure which one fits the recipe in front of you, that is exactly what Eat Well Planner's AI recipe chat is for. Ask "I'm out of allspice, what should I use in this?" and it answers with your actual recipe in context, including which spices are already in it, so it will not suggest more cinnamon for a dish that already calls for a tablespoon. And if you are using the swap as a chance to cut the sugar in a bake, the Recipe Playground shows how each change moves the nutrition score before you commit to it.