Maybe the bell pepper in the crisper went soft and wrinkly before you got to it. Maybe someone at your table can't eat peppers, or you're keeping nightshades off the menu for a few weeks to see how you feel. Or maybe you just looked at the price of three red peppers and decided dinner could do without them. Whatever brought you here, the good news is that bell peppers are easy to replace, as long as you match the swap to what the pepper is actually doing in your recipe.
And bell peppers do very different jobs. In stuffed peppers they're an edible bowl. In fajitas and stir-fries they're sweet, crisp-tender strips that char at the edges. In gumbo, jambalaya, chili, and sauces they're part of the flavor base, and in salads and crudités they're raw crunch and color. The best substitute for one job is often useless for another, so this guide is organized by use, with exact amounts for each. Every substitute is also marked as nightshade-free or not, since that's the first question for a lot of people searching this.
Two numbers to keep handy: by USDA weights, one medium bell pepper is about 4 ounces (119 g) and one large is about 6 ounces (164 g), while a cup of chopped pepper weighs about 5 ounces (149 g). So one medium pepper gives you a heaping 3/4 cup chopped, and a large one gives you about 1 cup. Most swaps below replace pepper cup for cup, so convert your recipe's "1 large bell pepper" to "1 cup chopped" and measure from there.
The Quick List
- A different color bell pepper or mini sweet peppers — the obvious swap for everything; just adjust for sweetness
- Poblano peppers — the best stuffed-pepper swap, and excellent in fajitas (mildly hot)
- Cubanelle or Italian frying peppers — closest flavor for sautés, sausage and peppers, and sandwiches
- Anaheim peppers — great in fajitas, rajas, and Tex-Mex dishes (mild to medium heat)
- Jarred roasted red peppers or pimientos — sauces, soups, dips, pasta, and sandwiches; no crunch
- Zucchini (nightshade-free) — stuffed "boats," fajitas, kabobs, and stir-fries
- Portobello mushrooms (nightshade-free) — stuffed caps and meaty fajitas
- Celery (nightshade-free) — the go-to swap in gumbo, jambalaya, chili, and tuna or chicken salad
- Carrots (nightshade-free) — sweetness and color in stir-fries, slaws, sauces, and soups
- Fennel (nightshade-free) — sautés, sausage and "peppers," and roasted vegetable trays
- Snap peas, snow peas, or broccoli (nightshade-free) — stir-fries, with vitamin C to match
- Extra onion (nightshade-free) — fajitas and sautés where peppers and onions share the pan
- Kohlrabi, jicama, or radishes (nightshade-free) — raw crunch for salads and veggie platters
First: Which Substitutes Are Nightshade-Free?
Bell peppers belong to the nightshade family, along with tomatoes, white potatoes (not sweet potatoes), eggplant, tomatillos, goji berries, and every chile pepper. That means poblanos, Anaheims, cubanelles, jarred roasted peppers, and pimientos are all nightshades too. They solve an empty-crisper problem, but they don't solve a nightshade problem.
The same goes for spices made from dried peppers: paprika, smoked paprika, cayenne, chili powder, red pepper flakes, and most taco and Cajun seasoning blends. If you're avoiding peppers because of an allergy or a sensitivity, read your spice labels, because ground pepper in a blend is easy to miss. Black pepper is a different plant entirely and is fine.
For what it's worth, the evidence that nightshades cause trouble for most people is thin. The Cleveland Clinic says there's no proof nightshades cause inflammation in general, while noting that people with inflammatory or autoimmune conditions like arthritis, psoriasis, and possibly inflammatory bowel disease may benefit from eating fewer of them, and that a short trial elimination with a healthcare provider's help is a reasonable way to find out. Either way, every substitute marked "nightshade-free" below is safe for that experiment.
For Stuffed Peppers
Stuffed peppers need a sturdy vessel that holds its shape in the oven and tastes good with a savory filling. Most of the filling recipes (rice, ground meat or beans, tomato sauce, cheese) work in all of these, so you only need to change the container and the timing.
Poblano Peppers
- Swap: 1 poblano per bell pepper half, or about 1 poblano per 1/2 cup of filling
- Best for: Stuffed peppers, chiles rellenos, Tex-Mex and Mexican fillings
- Skip it for: Anyone who can't handle any heat, and raw salads (the flavor is grassy and strong raw)
- Nightshade-free: No
Poblanos are the best all-around stuffed pepper swap. They're wide enough to hold a real portion of filling, and they bring a deeper, earthier flavor than green bell peppers. They're mildly hot, usually 1,000 to 2,000 Scoville units against a jalapeño's 2,000 to 8,000, though individual peppers vary, so taste a sliver first if heat is a concern.
Instead of cutting off the top, slit each poblano lengthwise, scrape out the seeds and ribs (that's where much of the heat lives), and stuff it like a canoe. The walls are thinner than a bell pepper's, so poblanos cook faster: about 20 to 25 minutes at 375°F once stuffed with a precooked filling, compared with 35 to 45 minutes for most stuffed bell pepper recipes. For a smoky, softer result, char them under the broiler for a few minutes per side first and peel off the blistered skin.
Zucchini Boats
- Swap: 1 medium zucchini (2 boats) per bell pepper
- Best for: Any stuffed pepper filling, especially Italian-style beef, sausage, or rice fillings
- Skip it for: Long baking times; zucchini goes mushy if baked as long as peppers
- Nightshade-free: Yes
- Health notes: 17 calories per 100 g, a bit fewer than green bell pepper
Halve medium zucchini lengthwise, scoop out the seedy center with a spoon (leaving about 1/4 inch of flesh), and chop the scooped flesh into the filling so nothing goes to waste. Zucchini holds about as much filling per boat as a bell pepper half holds, and if you have filling left over, bake it alongside in a small dish.
Zucchini cooks much faster than bell pepper, so bake stuffed boats at 400°F for about 20 to 25 minutes, until the edges are tender when poked with a fork. Salting the hollowed boats and letting them sit cut-side down for 10 minutes draws out some water and keeps the filling from getting soggy. For more ways to use zucchini, see our zucchini substitutes guide, which runs this swap in the other direction.
Portobello Mushroom Caps
- Swap: 1 large portobello cap per bell pepper half (holds about 1/3 to 1/2 cup filling)
- Best for: Cheesy, savory, or Italian fillings; vegetarian stuffed peppers
- Skip it for: Huge portions of filling, since caps are shallow
- Nightshade-free: Yes
Portobellos are the meatiest stuffed-pepper swap, and their savory flavor works especially well with beef, sausage, or cheese fillings. Remove the stems and scrape out the dark gills with a spoon to make room for filling and keep it from turning gray. Mushrooms release water as they cook, so roast the empty caps gill-side up at 400°F for about 10 minutes, pour off the liquid, then fill and bake another 10 to 15 minutes. If you want more ideas built around mushrooms, our mushroom substitutes guide covers how they behave in different dishes.
Acorn Squash, Onions, or Cabbage Leaves
- Swap: 1 acorn squash half, 1 large hollowed onion, or 2 cabbage leaves per bell pepper half
- Best for: Hearty fall fillings (squash), Mediterranean fillings (onion), and casserole-style stuffed peppers (cabbage)
- Skip it for: Weeknights in a hurry; all three need precooking
- Nightshade-free: Yes
Acorn squash halves make generous, slightly sweet bowls. Roast them cut-side down at 400°F for 30 to 40 minutes until nearly tender, then flip, fill, and bake another 15 minutes. Large onions can be halved, parboiled for about 8 minutes, and separated into cup-shaped layers for small stuffed portions. And if you're making stuffed peppers mostly for the filling, roll it in blanched cabbage leaves and bake in sauce: you get stuffed cabbage, which is the same idea in a different wrapper.
For Fajitas, Stir-Fries, and Sautés
This is where bell peppers do most of their work, and where you have the most options. Bell pepper strips cook to crisp-tender in a few minutes over high heat, so the trick with substitutes is cutting them to cook in the same time.
Another Bell Pepper Color or Mini Sweet Peppers
- Swap: 1:1 by weight or volume
- Best for: Everything, including stuffing (mini peppers make great appetizer-size stuffed peppers)
- Skip it for: Nothing; just adjust for sweetness
- Nightshade-free: No
- Health notes: Ripe colors carry more vitamin C: per 100 g, green has 80 mg, red 128 mg, and yellow 184 mg
If your recipe calls for green and you have red, yellow, or orange, use them. Green bell peppers are simply unripe, so they taste grassier and slightly bitter, while the ripe colors are sweeter and fruitier. In a Cajun trinity or a classic Philly cheesesteak, swapping green for red makes the dish a little sweeter; in fajitas and stir-fries, almost nobody notices. Mini sweet peppers work cup for cup once seeded and sliced, and they need no other changes.
Going the other way, if a recipe wants the sweetness of red peppers and you only have green, a pinch of sugar or an extra minute of browning helps close the gap.
Cubanelle or Italian Frying Peppers
- Swap: 1:1 by weight; about 2 cubanelles per large bell pepper
- Best for: Sausage and peppers, sandwiches, sautés, frittatas, pizza
- Skip it for: Big stuffed peppers (they're narrow) and anything needing thick, crunchy strips
- Nightshade-free: No
Cubanelles, sometimes sold as Italian frying peppers or "Cuban peppers," are the closest flavor match to bell peppers. They're long, pale green to yellow, and sweet with at most a faint kick of about 1,000 Scoville units. The walls are thinner, so they soften and brown faster than bell peppers, which is exactly what you want in sausage and peppers or on a hoagie. Cut them into slightly wider strips than you'd cut a bell pepper, and pull them off the heat a minute or two sooner.
Anaheim Peppers
- Swap: 1:1 by weight; about 2 Anaheims per large bell pepper
- Best for: Fajitas, rajas, quesadillas, chili, Tex-Mex skillets, egg dishes
- Skip it for: Heat-sensitive eaters and mild dishes where a chile flavor would clash
- Nightshade-free: No
Anaheims are long, light green chiles from the New Mexico family, and they're the natural fajita swap: the flavor is brighter and more "chile" than bell pepper, and they char beautifully on a hot skillet. Heat ranges widely, from about 1,000 to 5,000 Scoville units, so one batch can be gentle and the next noticeably warm. If you're unsure, use half Anaheim and half onion, or remove the seeds and ribs. Poblanos work here too, sliced into strips (that's the Mexican dish rajas), with a deeper, earthier flavor.
One thing not to do: don't swap jalapeños in for bell pepper volume. A cup of jalapeño where the recipe wanted a cup of bell pepper is a very different dinner. If you want a little heat alongside a mild substitute, our jalapeño substitutes guide has milder ways to get it.
Zucchini or Summer Squash
- Swap: 1:1 by volume, cut into 1/2-inch-wide strips or 1-inch chunks (1 medium zucchini ≈ 1 1/2 cups chopped, replacing about 1 1/2 medium peppers)
- Best for: Fajitas, kabobs, stir-fries, sheet-pan dinners, pasta
- Skip it for: Raw dishes where you want crunch, and long-simmered sauces where it dissolves
- Nightshade-free: Yes
Zucchini takes the char of a hot pan almost as well as bell pepper does, and it's mild enough to soak up fajita or stir-fry seasoning. The difference is water: zucchini can turn soft and wet if crowded. Cook it over high heat in a single layer, add it toward the end of a stir-fry rather than at the start, and salt it at the end rather than the beginning. On kabobs, use thick half-moons so they don't fall off the skewer.
Fennel
- Swap: 1 fennel bulb ≈ 2 medium bell peppers by weight, sliced into 1/4-inch strips
- Best for: Sausage and "peppers," roasted vegetable trays, sautés, pasta, braises
- Skip it for: Tex-Mex dishes, where the anise flavor doesn't fit
- Nightshade-free: Yes
- Health notes: 3.1 g fiber per 100 g, nearly twice what green bell pepper has
Fennel is the underrated nightshade-free swap for Italian dishes. Raw, it tastes of licorice; cooked, that mellows into a gentle sweetness that plays the same role sweet peppers play next to sausage and onions. Trim the fronds and the stalks, halve the bulb, cut out the tough core, and slice. It takes a few more minutes than bell pepper to soften, so start it with the onions. Save the fronds and chop them over the finished dish like an herb.
Extra Onion
- Swap: Replace the pepper with an equal volume of sliced onion (or half onion, half another swap from this list)
- Best for: Fajitas, cheesesteaks, sausage sandwiches, sautés
- Skip it for: Raw salads, where that much onion overwhelms everything
- Nightshade-free: Yes
Peppers and onions share so many pans that the simplest fix is often just more onion. Sliced onion browns into the same sweet, slightly charred strips that peppers give fajitas and cheesesteaks. Mixing red and yellow onions adds back some of the color you lose. For a lighter, sweeter result, use sweet onions or add some sliced leeks. If you're short on onions too, our onion substitutes guide has you covered.
Snap Peas, Snow Peas, or Broccoli
- Swap: 1 cup per medium bell pepper (trim peas; cut broccoli into small florets)
- Best for: Stir-fries, sheet-pan chicken, grain bowls, noodle dishes
- Skip it for: Fajitas, stuffing, and anything where the dish depends on pepper flavor
- Nightshade-free: Yes
- Health notes: Broccoli has 89 mg vitamin C and 2.6 g fiber per 100 g, a bit more of both than green bell pepper
In a stir-fry, a bell pepper's main jobs are crunch, color, and quick cooking, and peas and broccoli do all three. Snap and snow peas need only a minute or two in a hot wok. Broccoli florets take a few minutes longer, so cut them small or add a splash of water and cover the pan for a minute to steam them through. Neither tastes like pepper, but in a dish built around soy, ginger, and garlic, nobody will miss it.
Carrots
- Swap: 1:1 by volume, sliced thin (about 1/8 inch) on a diagonal or cut into matchsticks; 2 medium carrots ≈ 1 cup chopped
- Best for: Stir-fries, fried rice, slaws, soups, and color on a sheet pan
- Skip it for: Fajitas and stuffing
- Nightshade-free: Yes
- Health notes: 2.8 g fiber per 100 g and plenty of beta-carotene, though far less vitamin C than peppers
Carrots bring back the sweetness and the bright color that red and orange peppers add, which matters more than people think in a dish that's otherwise beige. Because carrots are much denser, cut them thin and give them a head start: add them to a stir-fry 2 to 3 minutes before everything else. In a raw slaw or salad, julienned or shredded carrots are a direct swap for thinly sliced red pepper.
For Gumbo, Jambalaya, Chili, Soups, and Sauces
When peppers are chopped and cooked down into a flavor base, texture stops mattering and flavor takes over. That makes this the easiest category to substitute.
Celery
- Swap: 1:1 by volume; 1 medium bell pepper ≈ 2 medium stalks, chopped
- Best for: Cajun "holy trinity" dishes (gumbo, jambalaya, étouffée), chili, sloppy joes, soups, tuna and chicken salad
- Skip it for: Fajitas, stuffing, and dishes where you want sweetness
- Nightshade-free: Yes
Celery is the best swap for green bell pepper in a cooked base. Both are mildly bitter, grassy, and vegetal, and in the Cajun trinity of onion, celery, and green pepper, doubling the celery keeps the flavor balance closer to the original than any other swap. Chop it to the same size as the onion and cook it the same way. Raw, chopped celery also replaces bell pepper in tuna salad, chicken salad, and pasta salad, keeping the crunch with a milder flavor.
If you also want some sweetness back, which red peppers would have provided, add a chopped carrot along with the celery.
Jarred Roasted Red Peppers or Pimientos
- Swap: 1 whole jarred roasted pepper (or about 1/2 cup drained strips) per fresh bell pepper; 1 small 4-ounce jar of diced pimientos per 1/2 cup chopped red pepper
- Best for: Pasta sauces, soups, hummus and dips, sandwiches, grain salads, pimento cheese, quiche
- Skip it for: Stir-fries, fajitas, stuffing, and anything that needs crunch
- Nightshade-free: No
- Health notes: Brine-packed peppers are salty: USDA lists canned red peppers with their liquid at 1,370 mg sodium per 100 g, so drain and rinse them, or reach for pimientos, which USDA lists at just 14 mg
Jarred roasted peppers are already cooked, peeled, and soft, so they're useless for crunch but terrific anywhere red pepper gets blended or simmered. They add a smoky sweetness that fresh peppers only get after 20 minutes under the broiler. Drain them well before using, especially in sauces, or the brine will thin and oversalt the dish. Add them in the last few minutes of cooking rather than at the start, since they need warming, not cooking.
Pimientos are small, sweet red peppers sold diced in little jars. They're the classic in pimento cheese and a handy stand-in for chopped red pepper in casseroles, egg salad, and rice dishes.
Carrots, Zucchini, or Sun-Dried Tomatoes in Sauces
- Swap: 1:1 by volume, chopped and cooked down with the aromatics
- Best for: Chili, marinara, ragù, soups, and blended sauces
- Skip it for: Anywhere you want visible pepper pieces
- Nightshade-free: Carrots and zucchini yes; sun-dried tomatoes no
In a long-simmered chili or red sauce, chopped carrots replace the sweetness of red peppers and zucchini replaces the bulk. Both melt into the sauce if cooked long enough. If you're not avoiding nightshades and want a concentrated red-pepper-like depth, a couple of tablespoons of chopped sun-dried tomatoes do a lot of work in a small space. And if you need the smoky note of roasted peppers without the peppers, a pinch of smoked paprika gets you there (not for nightshade avoiders, since paprika is ground pepper).
For Salads, Crudités, and Raw Snacking
Raw bell pepper is all about crunch, juiciness, and a little sweetness, so the swaps here are the crisp, watery vegetables that are pleasant to eat raw.
Kohlrabi, Jicama, or Radishes
- Swap: 1:1 by volume, cut into sticks for dipping or thin slices for salads
- Best for: Veggie platters, chopped salads, slaws, grain bowls, lunchboxes
- Skip it for: Cooking as a pepper stand-in; they behave very differently with heat
- Nightshade-free: Yes
- Health notes: Kohlrabi brings 62 mg vitamin C and 3.6 g fiber per 100 g, one of the closest vitamin C matches to green bell pepper among nightshade-free vegetables
Kohlrabi is mild, crisp, and slightly sweet, somewhere between broccoli stem and apple. Peel off the tough outer skin and cut into sticks or matchsticks. Jicama is juicier and sweeter, perfect in Mexican-style salads and slaws where red pepper usually goes. Radishes are peppery and crunchy and add a pop of red that partly makes up for the missing red pepper. Cucumber, snap peas, and celery also earn a spot on any crudité platter that's missing peppers.
The Healthier Angle: Replacing a Vitamin C Powerhouse
Bell peppers don't need a healthier substitute; they're already one of the most nutrient-dense vegetables you can buy. A medium red bell pepper has about 150 mg of vitamin C, roughly 170% of the 90 mg daily value, and gram for gram red peppers carry more vitamin C than broccoli. So if you're cutting peppers out for more than a single meal, especially for a nightshade-free stretch, it's worth knowing where to make that vitamin C back up.
From the swaps above, broccoli (89 mg per 100 g), kohlrabi (62 mg), and snap or snow peas (60 mg) are your best bets, with cauliflower close behind. Celery, carrots, mushrooms, and onion are great for flavor and fiber but contribute very little vitamin C. Citrus, kiwi, and strawberries outside the recipe make up the rest easily. And any time you swap in a vegetable that isn't already in your weekly rotation, you've added one more plant to your week, which is the whole idea behind tracking plant diversity for gut health.
If you want to see what a swap does to a specific recipe before you commit, that's where Eat Well Planner comes in. Open any recipe in the Recipe Playground, swap the bell pepper for zucchini, fennel, or broccoli, and the nutrition score updates live, showing you what you gained and lost with each edit. Or let Make It Healthier propose swaps for you, with every suggested improvement verified by a nutrition calculator before you see it.
Take the Guesswork Out of Eating Well
Eat Well Planner helps you organize your favorite recipes, plan balanced meals, and automatically generate shopping lists — all in one place. Whether you're tracking macros, managing dietary restrictions, or just trying to stop asking "what's for dinner?", we've got you covered.
Our AI-powered tools can adapt any recipe to your dietary needs, help you discover new meals you'll love, and even log your nutrition effortlessly. It's meal planning made simple.
Start Organizing Your Meals — FreeWhat Not to Use
- Jalapeños or serranos in bell pepper quantities. They add heat, not bulk. Use a little alongside a mild swap if you want a kick, never cup for cup.
- Canned green chiles as a fajita swap. They're soft, wet, and salty, with no char or crunch. They're great stirred into a sauce or casserole, not as strips.
- Any pepper, paprika, or chili powder for a nightshade-free meal. Every Capsicum is a nightshade, sweet or hot, fresh, jarred, or ground.
- Eggplant or tomatoes for a nightshade-free stuffed "pepper." They're good stuffing vessels, but they're nightshades too. Zucchini, portobellos, and acorn squash are the safe picks.
- Cucumber in cooked dishes. It works raw, but cooked, it turns limp and watery in a stir-fry or fajita pan.
The Bottom Line
For stuffed peppers, use poblanos if peppers are allowed and zucchini boats or portobellos if they're not. For fajitas, use Anaheims or poblanos, or go nightshade-free with zucchini and extra onion. For stir-fries, use snap peas, broccoli, or carrots. For gumbo, chili, and sauces, use celery for green pepper and carrots or jarred roasted peppers for red. And for raw crunch, reach for kohlrabi, jicama, or radishes.
When you're not sure which of these fits the dish in front of you, ask Eat Well Planner's AI recipe chat. Unlike a general guide, it has your actual recipe in context, so "I'm out of bell peppers, what should I use?" gets an answer for that dish, down to the cut and cook time. If you're cooking nightshade-free for a while, Recipe Variations can rewrite the whole recipe with the substitutions already worked in, no line-by-line adapting required. You can try it free.