The pork belly is scored, the char siu marinade is half mixed, or the stir-fry sauce just needs its last spoonful of seasoning, and the five-spice jar is empty. Or you never bought one in the first place, because the recipe is the first one you have tried that calls for it.
The good news is that five-spice is not a single mystery ingredient. It is a blend, and the usual version is star anise, cloves, Chinese cinnamon (cassia), Sichuan pepper and fennel seed, according to its Wikipedia entry. Most kitchens have at least two or three of those, so you can rebuild it, or get most of the way there with a blend you already own. What matters is the licorice-and-warm-spice note from the star anise, fennel, cinnamon and cloves. The rest is detail.
All ratios below assume the recipe calls for ground five-spice powder and are per 1 teaspoon. The right pick also depends on what you are making: a roast pork rub, a braise and a batch of cookies each want a slightly different fix, so there is a match-the-dish list right after the quick list.
The Quick List
- DIY blend from ground spices — the closest match, works in everything five-spice goes in
- Cinnamon + star anise + cloves — the three-spice version that covers most of the flavor
- Allspice + fennel or anise seed — one jar plus the licorice note, good for rubs and roasts
- Garam masala + fennel — for roast meats and braises, not for baking
- Pumpkin pie spice + anise — the easy fix for cookies, cakes and spiced fruit
- Whole spices in the pot — the best option for red-braised pork, soups and simmered dishes
- Star anise alone — a single-spice fallback for braises and broths
- Allspice alone — the single jar most people have that gets closest
- Cinnamon alone — a last resort that works best in sweet recipes
Match the Substitute to the Dish
- Char siu, roast pork belly, roast duck, glazed ribs, dry rubs — DIY blend, cinnamon + star anise + cloves, allspice + fennel, garam masala + fennel
- Stir-fries, noodle sauces, marinades — DIY blend, cinnamon + star anise + cloves, allspice + fennel (use a light hand)
- Red-braised pork, beef stew, braised short ribs, soups — whole spices in the pot, star anise alone, DIY blend
- Cookies, gingerbread, spice cake, apple pie, roasted pears — pumpkin pie spice + anise, cinnamon + star anise + cloves, cinnamon alone
- Spiced nuts, roasted carrots or squash, five-spice salt for dipping — DIY blend, allspice + fennel
DIY Five-Spice From Ground Spices
- Swap: 1 teaspoon five-spice → 1/4 teaspoon ground cinnamon + 1/4 teaspoon ground star anise (or ground anise seed) + 1/4 teaspoon ground fennel + 1/8 teaspoon ground cloves + 1/8 teaspoon ground Sichuan pepper (or white or black pepper)
- Best for: Everything: rubs, marinades, braises, stir-fry sauces, baking
- Skip it for: Nothing in particular; it is the first choice whenever you have most of the spices
There is no single official recipe. Brands and home cooks all weight the five spices differently, and The Woks of Life notes that blends vary and you can adjust the proportions to suit your taste. The version above leans on the licorice spices and keeps the cloves small. Cloves are the strongest flavor in the mix, and too much of them makes a sauce taste medicinal. Stir everything together in a small bowl before adding it so nothing clumps in one spot.
If you are missing one of the five, the blend still works. No Sichuan pepper is the most common gap. White pepper is the usual stand-in, and it is what American-style blends use. Black pepper works too. Neither gives you the floral, lemony tingle of Sichuan pepper, but in a sauce or rub with other strong flavors that is the part you will miss least. No fennel? Use 1/2 teaspoon of star anise or anise seed instead of 1/4 teaspoon of each. No star anise or anise seed? Double the fennel.
Making a Batch From Whole Spices
If you cook with five-spice often, a jar ground from whole spices is noticeably more fragrant than store-bought. Cook's Illustrated's version makes about 1/4 cup:
- 1 tablespoon whole cloves
- 2 1/2 teaspoons fennel seeds
- 4 teaspoons Sichuan peppercorns (or 2 teaspoons white peppercorns)
- 4 to 6 star anise pods, depending on size
- 1 cinnamon stick, 5 to 6 inches long
Grind the cloves, fennel and peppercorns in a spice grinder for 20 to 30 seconds, then grind the star anise and broken-up cinnamon stick separately and stir it all together. Many cooks toast the whole spices in a dry pan for a minute or two first, until fragrant. Let them cool before grinding. Store the jar somewhere cool, dark and dry. Freshly ground five-spice is stronger than an old jar, so start with a little less than the recipe asks for and taste.
Cinnamon + Star Anise + Cloves
- Swap: 1 teaspoon five-spice → 1/2 teaspoon ground cinnamon + 1/4 teaspoon ground star anise (or ground anise seed) + 1/8 teaspoon ground cloves, plus a pinch of black or white pepper if you have it
- Best for: Glazes, roast pork, braises, stir-fry sauces, baking
- Skip it for: Nothing specific; it is just slightly sweeter and less complex than the full blend
These three spices carry most of what five-spice tastes like. The star anise brings the licorice, the cinnamon brings the sweetness and the cloves bring the warm, pungent depth. Leaving out fennel and Sichuan pepper takes away some of the brightness, and the cinnamon picks up the slack, so the result reads a little sweeter. In a honey-glazed pork or a spice cake, that is barely noticeable.
Most American cinnamon is cassia, the same Chinese cinnamon used in traditional five-spice, so the regular jar in your cabinet is the right one. If you only have whole star anise, grind a pod or two in a spice grinder or crush it finely with a mortar and pestle. Out of cinnamon too? Our cinnamon substitutes guide covers that side.
Allspice + Fennel or Anise Seed
- Swap: 1 teaspoon five-spice → 3/4 teaspoon ground allspice + 1/4 teaspoon ground fennel or anise seed (crush whole seeds finely)
- Best for: Dry rubs, roast pork and chicken, glazed ribs, marinades, spiced nuts
- Skip it for: Delicate sauces where five-spice is the only seasoning; it is close, but not identical
Allspice is a single berry that tastes like a blend of cinnamon, cloves and nutmeg, so it covers three of the five-spice notes in one jar. What it does not have is the licorice flavor, which is the defining part of five-spice. A little fennel or anise seed adds that back. Fennel is milder and slightly sweet. Anise seed is closer to star anise and a bit stronger.
If you only have whole seeds, crush them in a mortar and pestle or with the bottom of a heavy pan and measure after crushing. In a long-cooked braise, you can leave them whole and add them to the liquid. If you are short on allspice too, our allspice substitutes guide shows how to build it from cinnamon, nutmeg and cloves.
Garam Masala + Fennel
- Swap: 1 teaspoon five-spice → 3/4 teaspoon garam masala + 1/4 teaspoon ground fennel or anise seed
- Best for: Roast pork, chicken thighs, beef stew, braised short ribs, roasted vegetables
- Skip it for: Baking, desserts and light stir-fry sauces
Garam masala shares cinnamon, cloves and pepper with five-spice, which is why it works better than you might expect in roasts and braises. But most blends also include cumin, coriander and cardamom, which five-spice does not have, so the result tastes a little more like a curry. The fennel brings back the licorice note and pulls the flavor toward Chinese.
Use it where there are plenty of other strong flavors around it: soy sauce, garlic, ginger, honey, rich meat. In a simple honey-ginger glaze or a cookie dough, the cumin stands out. Blends vary a lot, so check what is in yours. Our garam masala guide breaks down what is typically in the jar.
Pumpkin Pie Spice + Anise (for Baking)
- Swap: 1 teaspoon five-spice → 3/4 teaspoon pumpkin pie spice + 1/4 teaspoon ground anise seed, star anise or fennel
- Best for: Five-spice cookies, gingerbread, spice cake, apple or pear desserts, spiced granola
- Skip it for: Savory dishes, where the ginger and nutmeg taste out of place
Five-spice turns up in plenty of baking recipes, where it gives cookies, gingerbread and fruit desserts a warm, slightly mysterious edge. Pumpkin pie spice already has the cinnamon and cloves, and it is built for baked goods. The pinch of anise is what makes it taste like five-spice instead of Thanksgiving.
Pumpkin pie spice also brings ginger and nutmeg, which five-spice usually does not. In a gingerbread or a spice cake that is a bonus. In a recipe where five-spice is the only spice, the result will taste a bit softer and more familiar than the original. See our pumpkin pie spice guide for what goes into the blend and how to make it from scratch.
Whole Spices in the Pot (for Braises and Soups)
- Swap: 1 teaspoon five-spice → 2 whole star anise pods + one 3-inch cinnamon stick + 3 to 4 whole cloves + 1/2 teaspoon fennel seeds, plus 1/2 teaspoon Sichuan or black peppercorns if you have them
- Best for: Red-braised pork, braised beef or short ribs, soy-braised eggs, soups, poaching liquids
- Skip it for: Rubs, quick stir-fries and baking, where the spices need to be ground
In a dish that simmers for an hour or more, you do not need ground spices at all. Whole spices dropped into the braising liquid release their flavor slowly and give a cleaner, rounder result than powder, which can turn a little muddy over long cooking. This is how many traditional red-braised dishes are flavored anyway: whole star anise and cinnamon in the pot, with the spices fished out before serving.
Treat the amounts above as a starting point for a pot with about 2 pounds of meat. Taste the liquid after 30 minutes. Star anise gets stronger the longer it simmers, so if the licorice note is already clear, pull a pod out. Put the small spices in a tea ball or a square of cheesecloth if you do not want to pick out cloves later.
Star Anise Alone
- Swap: 1 teaspoon five-spice → 1/2 teaspoon ground star anise, or 1 to 2 whole pods in a braise or soup
- Best for: Braises, broths, soy-based glazes, roast duck
- Skip it for: Baking and dry rubs where five-spice is the only spice
Star anise is the biggest single flavor in most five-spice blends, so it is the best one-jar fallback for savory dishes. It is also strong, which is why the swap is half the amount. On its own, it will taste more purely of licorice than five-spice does. If you have even a pinch of ground cinnamon or cloves, add it.
Allspice Alone
- Swap: 1 teaspoon five-spice → 1/2 to 3/4 teaspoon ground allspice
- Best for: Rubs, glazes, marinades, meatballs, baking
- Skip it for: Recipes where the licorice note is the point, like five-spice salt or roast duck
Allspice gets you the warm half of five-spice (cinnamon, cloves, a peppery edge) with no licorice. That makes the dish taste warmly spiced but not quite Chinese. Start at half the amount, because allspice is stronger than five-spice. Add more only after tasting.
Cinnamon Alone
- Swap: 1 teaspoon five-spice → 1/2 teaspoon ground cinnamon
- Best for: Baking, roasted squash or sweet potatoes, oatmeal, sweet glazes
- Skip it for: Char siu, roast duck and dishes where five-spice is the main flavor
This is the last resort. Cinnamon is part of five-spice, so it fits, but it covers only one of the five notes. In a cookie or a sweet potato dish where five-spice is one of several flavors, it is fine. In a pork rub, the result will taste sweet and flat. If you have a whole clove, crush it and add the powder; it closes a surprising amount of the gap.
Take the Guesswork Out of Eating Well
Eat Well Planner helps you organize your favorite recipes, plan balanced meals, and automatically generate shopping lists — all in one place. Whether you're tracking macros, managing dietary restrictions, or just trying to stop asking "what's for dinner?", we've got you covered.
Our AI-powered tools can adapt any recipe to your dietary needs, help you discover new meals you'll love, and even log your nutrition effortlessly. It's meal planning made simple.
Start Organizing Your Meals — FreeWhat About the Health Side?
You use five-spice by the teaspoon, so swapping one spice for another will not change the nutrition of a dish in any meaningful way. A few things are still worth knowing.
- Plain five-spice has no salt, but check the label. Most jars are just the ground spices. Some blends and "five-spice seasoning" mixes include salt or sugar, though, so check the ingredient list and go easy on any salt the recipe adds separately. The homemade blends above are salt-free.
- A dry rub can replace a sugary sauce. A lot of five-spice dishes come with a glaze or sauce made from hoisin, honey or sugar. USDA data puts bottled hoisin at 4.4 g of sugar and 258 mg of sodium per tablespoon. Leaning harder on the spice and a little less on the bottle keeps the flavor and cuts both. If you are out of the sauce too, our hoisin sauce substitutes include a homemade version where you control the sugar.
- Spices make it easier to cut salt. In the SPICE trial summarized by Harvard's Nutrition Source, 40 adults who learned to cook with spices and herbs in place of salt ended up eating about 957 mg less sodium per day than a control group after 20 weeks. It was a small study, but the idea is easy to use: a well-spiced dish needs less salt to taste finished.
- Buy culinary star anise, and do not brew it into tea. Chinese star anise, the spice, is generally recognized as safe. Japanese star anise is a different, toxic plant, and the two cannot be told apart once dried. In 2003 the FDA warned consumers against drinking teas brewed from star anise after about 40 people, including 15 infants, became ill. Buying star anise from a regular spice brand at the grocery store is the normal, sensible choice.
A Healthier Use for Your Substitute
Five-spice is one of the easiest ways to make vegetables taste like something you want to eat. Toss carrots, squash, sweet potatoes or Brussels sprouts with a little oil, a teaspoon of five-spice (or the DIY blend) and a pinch of salt, then roast them. The warm, slightly sweet spice does what a sugary glaze would, without the sugar. It works the same way on tofu, salmon and chicken.
The homemade blend has one more small advantage. If you track plant diversity, each herb and spice counts as a quarter point in Eat Well Planner's Plant Points, so a blend made from four or five separate spices adds a little to your weekly total. On its own that is minor. Alongside the vegetables in a stir-fry, it adds up.
What Not to Use
- Equal amounts of ground cloves or star anise: Both are much stronger than five-spice. A full teaspoon of either in place of five-spice can make a sauce bitter or medicinal. Stick to the half-amount swaps above.
- Plain curry powder: It shares a few spices, but turmeric, cumin and coriander dominate it, and the dish will taste like a curry, not char siu.
- Licorice candy or anise extract: Anise extract is very concentrated and mostly sweet. A drop or two can work in a cookie dough. In a savory sauce, it tastes artificial.
- Garam masala in baking: The cumin and coriander that make it great in a braise taste odd in a cookie. Use pumpkin pie spice with a pinch of anise instead.
- Chili sauce or chili flakes for Sichuan pepper: Despite the name, Sichuan pepper is not closely related to black pepper or chili peppers. A chili sauce adds heat that five-spice does not have. If you are missing Sichuan pepper, use white or black pepper.
- Hoisin sauce as a spice substitute: Hoisin contains some warm spice, but it is mostly sugar, salt and soybean paste. Adding it to replace five-spice changes the sweetness and salt of the whole dish. Use it only if the recipe already calls for a sauce like it.
Which Five-Spice Substitute Should You Use?
If you have most of the spices, mix 1/4 teaspoon each of cinnamon, star anise and fennel with 1/8 teaspoon each of cloves and pepper for every teaspoon of five-spice. With only three, use cinnamon, star anise and cloves. For rubs and roast pork, allspice with a little fennel is the best one-jar fix, and garam masala with fennel works too. For cookies and cakes, use pumpkin pie spice with a pinch of anise. For a braise or soup, skip the powder and drop whole star anise, a cinnamon stick and a few cloves into the pot.
If you are not sure which one fits the recipe in front of you, ask Eat Well Planner's AI recipe chat. Something like "I'm out of five-spice, what should I use in this?" gets an answer with your actual recipe in context, including which spices are already in it. It will not suggest more cinnamon for a dish that already uses a stick. And if you want to see what leaning on a dry rub instead of a sugary glaze does to a dish, the Recipe Playground shows the nutrition score change with each swap before you commit to it.