All Substitution Guides

11 Substitutes for Pesto (for Pasta, Sandwiches, Pizza, and Grilled Food)

Substitution Guide
11 Substitutes for Pesto (for Pasta, Sandwiches, Pizza, and Grilled Food)

The pasta water is boiling, the recipe says "toss with 1/2 cup pesto," and the jar in the fridge turns out to hold a dried green crust and a smear of oil. Or the jar is fine, but the person you are cooking for cannot eat nuts, or dairy, or simply does not like basil.

The good news is that pesto is a style of sauce more than a single recipe: something green or bright, something rich, something salty, all loosened with oil. Most kitchens have at least one way to rebuild that, and the Mediterranean has several other sauces that do the same job, sometimes better. Which one you want depends on what the pesto was for: coating pasta, spreading on a sandwich, sitting under pizza toppings, or spooned over grilled chicken or fish.

Here is what works for each, with ratios, and with notes on which swaps keep the dish lighter than the jar would have.

The Quick List

  • Five-minute pantry pesto — any tender greens plus any nut or seed plus any hard cheese; the closest match for everything
  • Spinach, kale, or arugula pesto — the classic texture with no basil at all
  • Sun-dried tomato pesto — the best pizza and sandwich swap, rich and tangy
  • Pistou — pesto's nut-free, cheese-free French cousin; just basil, garlic, and oil
  • Garlic and herb olive oil — the fastest pasta and white-pizza swap, made from what is already in the pantry
  • Italian salsa verde — bright, briny, and herb-heavy; superb on fish, potatoes, and grain bowls
  • Chimichurri — the swap for steak, chicken, and grilled vegetables
  • Olive tapenade — a bold sandwich spread and pizza base; use about half as much
  • Herby Greek yogurt or ricotta — a creamy, higher-protein swap for pasta and wraps
  • Hummus — the easiest sandwich and wrap spread, with fewer calories and more fiber
  • Gremolata — an oil-free finishing sprinkle for fish, soup, and roasted vegetables

Match the Swap to the Dish

If you only read one section, read this one. The ratios below use 1/4 cup of pesto as the base, which is about what a sandwich for two, a 12-inch pizza, or a half pound of pasta calls for. For a full pound of pasta, plan on about 1/2 cup of sauce plus a splash of the starchy cooking water.

  • Pasta: Pantry pesto, spinach or kale pesto, pistou, garlic and herb oil, herby ricotta, or sun-dried tomato pesto. Salsa verde and chimichurri work in pasta salads but taste sharp on hot pasta.
  • Sandwiches, wraps, and paninis: Sun-dried tomato pesto, tapenade, hummus, or herby Greek yogurt. Thin, oily sauces like chimichurri soak into the bread.
  • Pizza and flatbreads: Sun-dried tomato pesto, garlic oil, a thin layer of tapenade, or ricotta under the toppings. Bright herb sauces (salsa verde, chimichurri, pistou) are best spooned on after baking.
  • Grilled meat, fish, and vegetables: Chimichurri, salsa verde, or gremolata, any of which may beat the pesto you planned.
  • Soups and stews: Pistou, which was made for exactly this, or gremolata.

Five-Minute Pantry Pesto

  • Swap: 1/2 cup pesto → 1 packed cup tender greens or herbs + 3 tablespoons nuts or seeds + 1/4 cup grated hard cheese + 1 small garlic clove + 1/4 cup olive oil + a squeeze of lemon and a pinch of salt, blended
  • Best for: Everything pesto does: pasta, sandwiches, pizza, drizzling
  • Skip it for: Nothing, really; the only limit is what is in your fridge

Pesto is a formula, and once you see it that way you can almost always make some. You need about two parts green, one part rich (nuts, seeds, or both nuts and cheese), a little garlic, an acid if you have one, and enough oil to loosen it into a sauce. Basil, parsley, cilantro, baby spinach, arugula, kale, the tops of carrots, or a mix of whatever herbs are wilting in the drawer all count as "green." Walnuts, almonds, cashews, sunflower seeds, or pepitas can stand in for pine nuts, and our pine nut substitutes guide has toasting times and notes on each. Parmesan, pecorino, aged Asiago, or even a spoonful of nutritional yeast covers the cheese.

Pulse the nuts, garlic, and cheese first until crumbly, add the greens and pulse again, then stream in the oil with the motor running. Taste and adjust with salt and lemon. A food processor is easiest, a blender works if you scrape down the sides, and a sharp knife and five minutes of chopping makes a rustic version that is lovely on pasta. If you have no fresh greens at all, blend whatever you do have (even frozen spinach, thawed and squeezed dry) with 1 teaspoon of dried basil per cup of greens, which brings back some of the herb note.

Spinach, Kale, or Arugula Pesto

  • Swap: 1:1 for basil pesto; use 2 packed cups of greens per 1/2 cup of oil, same as basil
  • Best for: Pasta, grain bowls, sandwiches, freezing in batches
  • Skip it for: Recipes where pesto is the only flavor, like pesto on plain bread; spinach alone tastes mild
  • Health notes: Leafy greens bring vitamin K, folate, and a deeper green color for a fraction of the cost of basil

Each green behaves differently. Baby spinach is mild and silky, so it needs extra garlic, lemon zest, and cheese to taste like anything; it is also the best way to stretch half a bunch of real basil into a full batch. Arugula is peppery and has enough personality to stand on its own. Kale is the sturdiest and most bitter. Strip the stems, and if the leaves are mature, blanch them for 30 seconds and squeeze them dry first, which softens the bitterness and keeps the color vivid. Our fresh basil substitutes guide goes deeper on making pesto without basil.

One note if you take a blood thinner such as warfarin: two cups of spinach or kale puts a batch of pesto well past a day's worth of vitamin K. That is not a reason to avoid it, but consistency matters with those medications, so keep an eye on how often you eat it.

Sun-Dried Tomato Pesto

  • Swap: 1:1 for basil pesto. To make about 1 cup: 1 cup oil-packed sun-dried tomatoes (drained), 1/4 cup walnuts or almonds, 1/3 cup grated Parmesan, 1 garlic clove, a handful of basil or parsley if you have it, 1 teaspoon red wine vinegar, and 1/4 to 1/3 cup olive oil (use some of the oil from the jar)
  • Best for: Pizza, paninis and wraps, pasta, stirring into soups, spreading under roasted chicken
  • Skip it for: Dishes where you want a fresh, green, herbal flavor

Sun-dried tomato pesto, often called pesto rosso, is the most versatile swap after a homemade green pesto, and in sandwiches and on pizza it arguably beats the original. It is sweet, tangy, and savory, it spreads thickly without soaking into bread, and it holds up in the oven where basil turns dark. Because the tomatoes provide so much body, it needs less oil than basil pesto does.

Blend everything except the oil, then add oil until it reaches the consistency you want: thicker for sandwiches, looser for pasta. If you only have dry-packed tomatoes, soak them in hot water for 10 minutes and drain before using. Out of those too? Our sun-dried tomato substitutes guide covers what to use instead, and a couple of tablespoons of tomato paste cooked briefly in olive oil with garlic gets you surprisingly close for pasta.

Pistou

  • Swap: 1:1 for pesto. To make about 1/2 cup: 2 packed cups basil, 2 garlic cloves, 1/3 cup olive oil, and a good pinch of salt, pounded or blended
  • Best for: Soups (especially minestrone and white bean soup), pasta, drizzling over tomatoes and grilled vegetables, nut-free and dairy-free cooking
  • Skip it for: Sandwiches, where it is too thin and oily, and anywhere you need the sauce to cling and coat heavily

If you have basil but no nuts or cheese, you do not need a substitute at all; you need pistou. It is the Provençal sauce made mainly from garlic, fresh basil, and olive oil, traditionally without the pine nuts and cheese of Genovese pesto, and best known for being stirred into soupe au pistou just before serving. Some cooks in Provence add grated cheese, so feel free to if you have it and it is not an allergy issue.

Without nuts, pistou is thinner and more intensely herbal than pesto, and it does not cling to pasta quite as well. Toss it with the pasta and a few spoonfuls of starchy pasta water off the heat, which helps it coat. It is naturally vegan and nut-free, which makes it the simplest answer when you are cooking for someone with either restriction.

Garlic and Herb Olive Oil

  • Swap: For 1/2 pound of pasta, in place of 1/4 cup pesto: 3 tablespoons olive oil warmed gently with 2 sliced garlic cloves and a pinch of red pepper flakes, then tossed with 2 tablespoons grated Parmesan, a handful of chopped parsley or basil, and some pasta water
  • Best for: Weeknight pasta, white pizza and flatbreads, brushing on bread or grilled vegetables
  • Skip it for: Sandwiches and cold pasta salads that need a thick, clinging sauce

This is essentially pasta aglio e olio with herbs and cheese, and it uses ingredients you almost certainly have. Warm the oil and garlic together over low heat until the garlic is fragrant and just barely golden at the edges, about 3 to 4 minutes; browned garlic turns bitter fast. Toss it with the drained pasta, the cheese, the herbs, and a splash of cooking water until glossy. Lemon zest at the end makes it taste even more like pesto.

For pizza, brush the same garlic oil over the dough instead of sauce, top with mozzarella and vegetables, and finish with fresh basil or arugula after baking. Our olive oil substitutes guide covers the rare kitchen that is out of olive oil too.

Italian Salsa Verde

  • Swap: 1:1 for pesto as a sauce or drizzle. To make about 3/4 cup: 1 cup finely chopped flat-leaf parsley, 2 tablespoons capers (chopped), 1 to 2 anchovy fillets (optional), 1 small garlic clove, zest and juice of 1/2 lemon or 1 tablespoon red wine vinegar, and 1/2 cup olive oil
  • Best for: Grilled or roasted fish, chicken, boiled potatoes, white beans, grain bowls, roasted vegetables, pasta salad
  • Skip it for: Hot pasta as a main sauce (it reads sharp and thin), and baking on pizza

Italian salsa verde is pesto's brighter, punchier relative: no nuts, no cheese, and a hit of acid and brine from capers and sometimes anchovies. It is the swap to reach for when pesto was meant to be spooned over a piece of salmon, a pan of roasted potatoes, or a pot of beans, and many people end up preferring it there. It is also nut-free and dairy-free, and vegan if you leave out the anchovies.

Chop by hand if you can; a food processor tends to turn parsley into a dull, wet puree. Add the acid shortly before serving, since lemon and vinegar dull the green color within an hour or two. Our guides to capers and anchovies cover what to do if either of those is missing. Do not confuse it with Mexican salsa verde, which is a tomatillo and chile salsa and is a different thing entirely.

Chimichurri

  • Swap: 1:1 for pesto as a topping or marinade. To make about 3/4 cup: 1 cup finely chopped flat-leaf parsley, 3 garlic cloves (minced), 1 teaspoon dried oregano, 1/2 teaspoon red pepper flakes, 3 tablespoons red wine vinegar, 1/2 cup olive oil, and salt to taste
  • Best for: Steak, grilled chicken, sausages, fish, grilled or roasted vegetables, eggs, grain bowls
  • Skip it for: Sandwich spreads (it is thin and soaks in) and creamy pasta dishes

Chimichurri comes from Argentina, where it is built from flat-leaf parsley, garlic, olive oil, oregano, chiles, and red wine vinegar or lemon juice and served at the table with grilled meat. If your pesto was headed for a steak, chicken thighs, or a tray of grilled zucchini, chimichurri is not a compromise; it is arguably the better sauce, because the vinegar cuts through rich, charred food in a way pesto's cheese and nuts cannot.

It is looser and sharper than pesto, more of an herby vinaigrette than a paste. Let it sit for 15 to 20 minutes before serving so the garlic mellows and the oregano softens. It also doubles as a marinade: coat chicken or vegetables with a few tablespoons and refrigerate for 30 minutes to a few hours before grilling, keeping some fresh sauce aside for serving. Our fresh parsley substitutes guide covers cilantro and other herbs if you are short on parsley.

Olive Tapenade

  • Swap: 1/4 cup pesto → about 2 tablespoons tapenade, or tapenade thinned with an equal amount of olive oil for pasta
  • Best for: Sandwiches and paninis, crostini, a thin pizza base, stirring into pasta with tomatoes
  • Skip it for: Dishes for olive skeptics, and anything that needs a mild, green sauce
  • Health notes: About 42 calories per tablespoon, roughly a third fewer than shelf-stable pesto

Tapenade is a Provençal paste of olives and capers chopped with olive oil, sometimes with garlic, herbs, anchovies, or lemon. The name comes from the Provençal word for capers. It is much bolder and more briny than pesto, so use it at about half the volume, and pair it with something mild: fresh mozzarella, roasted peppers, tomatoes, or turkey on a sandwich.

For a quick homemade version, pulse 1 cup pitted Kalamata or black olives with 1 tablespoon capers, 1 small garlic clove, a squeeze of lemon, and 2 to 3 tablespoons olive oil. On pizza, spread it thinly; a heavy layer gets salty under melted cheese. On the numbers, USDA data for olive tapenade works out to about 42 calories and 125 mg of sodium per tablespoon, against about 65 calories and 150 mg for shelf-stable jarred pesto, and since you use about half as much, the sandwich ends up lighter.

Herby Greek Yogurt or Ricotta

  • Swap for pasta: 1/4 cup pesto → 1/3 cup part-skim ricotta + 1 tablespoon olive oil + 1 tablespoon grated Parmesan + lemon zest + chopped herbs, loosened with 2 to 4 tablespoons hot pasta water
  • Swap for sandwiches and wraps: 2 tablespoons pesto → 2 tablespoons plain Greek yogurt + 1 teaspoon olive oil + a little grated garlic, lemon, salt, and chopped herbs
  • Best for: Creamy pasta, chicken wraps, grain bowls, a dip for vegetables
  • Skip it for: Baking on pizza (yogurt can split; ricotta in dollops is fine), and dairy-free cooking

A creamy herb sauce gets you a lot of pesto's richness with more protein and much less oil. Ricotta melts into a silky sauce on hot pasta, especially with a little cooking water and lemon zest, and dollops of it on pizza before baking are classic. Greek yogurt with garlic and herbs makes an excellent, tangy spread for wraps and sandwiches, and it is the base of many Mediterranean sauces for grilled meat.

The best trick here is stretching. If you have a couple of tablespoons of pesto left in the jar, stir them into an equal amount of Greek yogurt or ricotta and you have enough creamy pesto sauce for two servings of pasta or a stack of wraps, with the flavor of the real thing. Our guides to Greek yogurt and ricotta have more options.

Hummus

  • Swap: 1:1 for pesto on sandwiches and wraps; stir in a spoonful of chopped herbs or a drizzle of olive oil if you want it greener and richer
  • Best for: Sandwiches, wraps, veggie and chicken pitas, grain bowls
  • Skip it for: Pasta (it turns pasty and stodgy) and pizza
  • Health notes: About 71 calories, 1.6 g of fiber, and 128 mg of sodium per 2 tablespoons, versus about 130 calories and 300 mg of sodium for shelf-stable pesto

On a sandwich, pesto is mostly doing the job of a flavorful, moist spread, and hummus does that job well. It pairs naturally with the same fillings: roasted vegetables, turkey, chicken, tomato, cucumber, and greens. Blend a handful of basil, parsley, or spinach into plain hummus and you have something that looks and tastes halfway to pesto.

Per 2 tablespoons, USDA data for commercial hummus comes to roughly 71 calories, 5.3 g of fat, and 1.6 g of fiber, against about 130 calories and 13 g of fat for shelf-stable jarred pesto. The chickpeas also count as a plant, which nudges up plant diversity if you are aiming for 30 plants a week.

Gremolata

  • Swap: In place of a spoonful of pesto as a finish: 1/4 cup finely chopped parsley + zest of 1 lemon + 1 small garlic clove, minced together
  • Best for: Fish, braised meats, roasted vegetables, white bean soup, minestrone, risotto
  • Skip it for: Pasta sauce, sandwiches, and pizza, unless you mix it with olive oil first

Gremolata is the classic Italian finish for osso buco, and it delivers the fresh, green, garlicky lift of a spoonful of pesto with no oil, nuts, or cheese at all. Sprinkle it over a dish right before serving. If you need it to act more like a sauce, stir in 2 to 3 tablespoons of olive oil and you have something close to a quick salsa verde.

If You Are Swapping Because of an Allergy or Diet

  • Nut-free: Pistou, salsa verde, chimichurri, tapenade, gremolata, garlic oil, and pantry pesto made with sunflower seeds or pepitas. Pine nuts count as a tree nut for labeling purposes; see our pine nut guide for details.
  • Dairy-free: Pistou, salsa verde, chimichurri, tapenade, gremolata, hummus, and pantry pesto with nutritional yeast instead of cheese.
  • Vegetarian: Traditional Parmigiano-Reggiano is made with animal rennet, so check the label on store-bought pesto and cheese if that matters to you. Salsa verde and tapenade often contain anchovies.
  • Vegan: Pistou, chimichurri, anchovy-free salsa verde or tapenade, hummus, and nut or seed pesto with nutritional yeast.

Healthier Upgrade: A Lighter Pesto

Pesto is a wonderful sauce made from good ingredients, and you do not need to avoid it. But it is dense. Per 1/4 cup, USDA data puts shelf-stable jarred pesto at about 260 calories, 26 g of fat, and 609 mg of sodium, while refrigerated pesto comes in at a similar 263 calories but noticeably less sodium, about 380 mg. Most of the calories come from olive oil, which is a healthy fat, but at roughly 120 calories per tablespoon it adds up quickly when a recipe calls for a half cup of sauce.

If you are making pesto from scratch anyway, a few changes make it lighter without making it taste diet-y:

  • Swap half the oil for white beans. In a batch made with 2 cups basil and 1/2 cup oil, use 1/4 cup oil plus 1/2 cup rinsed canned white beans and 2 to 3 tablespoons of water. That cuts about 375 calories from the batch (roughly 475 from the oil, minus about 100 for the beans) and adds roughly 4 g of fiber and 6 g of protein (based on USDA data for canned white beans). The pesto turns creamier and slightly paler, and it clings to pasta beautifully.
  • Loosen it with pasta water, not more oil. A thick pesto thinned with starchy cooking water coats pasta as well as one thinned with oil.
  • Cut the cheese by a third and add lemon. Acid makes a sauce taste brighter and saltier than it is, so you miss less of what you took out.
  • Add more greens. Doubling the greens for the same amount of oil and nuts spreads the rich ingredients across more servings. Spinach is ideal for this.
  • Choose the sauce for the dish. On fish, chicken, and vegetables, salsa verde, chimichurri, and gremolata give you all of pesto's freshness with no cheese, and gremolata with no oil at all.

What you put pesto on matters as much as the sauce. Tossing it with whole wheat or bean-based pasta, plenty of vegetables, and some white beans or chicken turns a bowl of noodles into a balanced meal, and it means a smaller amount of sauce goes further.

Take the Guesswork Out of Eating Well

Eat Well Planner helps you organize your favorite recipes, plan balanced meals, and automatically generate shopping lists — all in one place. Whether you're tracking macros, managing dietary restrictions, or just trying to stop asking "what's for dinner?", we've got you covered.

Our AI-powered tools can adapt any recipe to your dietary needs, help you discover new meals you'll love, and even log your nutrition effortlessly. It's meal planning made simple.

Start Organizing Your Meals — Free

What Not to Use

  • Dried basil and oil on their own: Without fresh greens, the result tastes dusty and flat. Dried basil works as a booster in a spinach or parsley pesto, not as the main ingredient.
  • Mexican salsa verde: Despite the shared name, this tomatillo salsa is watery and acidic, and it does not coat pasta or spread on bread. Great on tacos, wrong here.
  • Straight tahini: It is thick, slightly bitter, and gluey on pasta. Thinned with lemon, water, and herbs it makes a fine sauce for bowls and vegetables, but it is a different dish.
  • Bottled Italian dressing: It has the herbs and the oil but is mostly vinegar, sugar, and stabilizers, and it slicks pasta rather than coating it.
  • Cooking any of these over high heat: Basil darkens and turns bitter, and cheese clumps. Whatever you use, toss it with hot pasta off the burner, or add herb sauces to pizza after it comes out of the oven.

Which Swap Fits Your Recipe?

The short version: make a pantry pesto from whatever greens and nuts you have if you can, reach for sun-dried tomato pesto or tapenade for sandwiches and pizza, pistou or garlic oil for pasta, and chimichurri or salsa verde for anything grilled. Where it gets trickier is the specific recipe in front of you, with its own balance of flavors and the people you are feeding.

That is what the AI recipe chat in Eat Well Planner is for. Ask it "I'm making this pesto chicken pasta and I'm out of pesto, what should I use?" and it answers with your actual recipe in context. If someone at the table cannot have nuts or dairy, Recipe Variations can rewrite the whole recipe with the swaps worked in. And if you are curious what the white-bean pesto or the chimichurri does to the dish's nutrition, Make It Healthier proposes swaps like these and verifies the real change in the recipe's nutrition score before suggesting them.

Weekly Tips, Free Forever

Eat Better Without
Overthinking It

More kitchen rescues like this — plus gut-friendly recipes and meal plans packed with fresh herbs and greens.