All Substitution Guides

8 Substitutes for Poultry Seasoning (for Stuffing, Roast Turkey, Gravy, and Soups)

Substitution Guide
8 Substitutes for Poultry Seasoning (for Stuffing, Roast Turkey, Gravy, and Soups)

The bread cubes are drying, the celery and onions are softening in butter, and the stuffing recipe says "1 1/2 teaspoons poultry seasoning." The jar you bought last November is either empty or nowhere to be found. Poultry seasoning is the classic once-a-year spice, so it tends to run out exactly when the kitchen is busiest.

The good news is that poultry seasoning is just a mix of everyday dried herbs, mostly sage and thyme, with a few supporting players. If you have even two of them, you can make a substitute that most people at the table will not notice, and with four or five jars you can make a blend that is fresher than the one you lost.

The best choice depends on what you are cooking. Stuffing and gravy want sage front and center, a roast turkey or chicken does well with almost any savory herb mix, and soups, pot pies and meatloaf are forgiving. All ratios below assume the recipe calls for dried poultry seasoning, measured in teaspoons or tablespoons.

The Quick List

  • Homemade poultry seasoning — the closest match, mixed in two minutes from dried thyme, sage, marjoram, rosemary, pepper and nutmeg
  • Dried sage + dried thyme — the best two-jar fix, and close enough for stuffing and gravy
  • A single dried herb — sage for stuffing and sausage, thyme for chicken, soups and vegetables
  • Fresh herbs — use about three times as much; excellent under turkey skin and in stuffing
  • Italian seasoning + sage — a shared base of thyme, marjoram and rosemary; add sage to make it taste like Thanksgiving
  • Herbes de Provence — good for roasts, with a pinch of sage; watch the lavender in gravy
  • Bell's Seasoning — the New England poultry blend, salt-free and a 1:1 swap if you have it
  • Sage breakfast sausage — a stuffing-only shortcut that brings sage, pepper and richness in one ingredient

What Poultry Seasoning Actually Is

Despite the name, poultry seasoning contains no chicken or turkey at all. It is a blend of dried herbs and spices meant to go with poultry, so it is fine for vegetarian stuffing, mushroom gravy and bean soups. It is also not the same thing as chicken bouillon powder or "chicken-flavored" seasoning, which are mostly salt and flavor enhancers.

The standard McCormick Poultry Seasoning lists just six ingredients: thyme, sage, marjoram, rosemary, black pepper and nutmeg. McCormick suggests it for roast turkey, bread stuffing and gravy, plus chicken soups, stews, pot pies, meatloaf and burgers. Thyme is listed first, but sage is the flavor most people recognize, because it is stronger and more distinctive. That piney, slightly musky sage note is what makes stuffing taste like stuffing. Get the sage and thyme right and everything else is fine-tuning.

For a sense of scale: poultry seasoning is used sparingly. McCormick's own classic herb stuffing uses only 1 1/2 teaspoons of poultry seasoning (plus 2 teaspoons of thyme) for 12 cups of bread cubes and 18 servings. A substitute that is a little off will not ruin anything; one that uses too much sage or rosemary will.

Match the Substitute to the Dish

  • Thanksgiving stuffing and dressing — homemade blend, sage + thyme, fresh herbs, Bell's Seasoning, sage breakfast sausage
  • Roast turkey and chicken (rubs, herb butter, under the skin) — homemade blend, fresh herbs, sage + thyme, Italian seasoning + sage, herbes de Provence
  • Gravies, chicken soup, pot pie and stews — homemade blend, sage + thyme, thyme alone, Italian seasoning + sage
  • Meatloaf, turkey burgers, meatballs and roasted vegetables — homemade blend, sage + thyme, Italian seasoning + sage, herbes de Provence

Homemade Poultry Seasoning

  • Swap: 1 tablespoon poultry seasoning → 1 teaspoon dried thyme + 1 teaspoon dried rubbed sage + 1/2 teaspoon dried marjoram (or oregano) + 1/4 teaspoon dried rosemary (crushed) + 1/8 teaspoon black pepper + a small pinch of nutmeg. Use it 1:1.
  • Best for: Everything poultry seasoning does: stuffing, roast turkey and chicken, gravy, soups, pot pie, meatloaf
  • Skip it for: Nothing in particular. If you have the herbs, this is the one to use.

This mix follows the same six ingredients as the store-bought jar, with thyme and sage in equal parts so neither one takes over. Rosemary stays small because it is the herb most likely to dominate, and dried rosemary needles are hard and pointy, so crush them between your fingers or with the back of a spoon first. Nutmeg is the secret ingredient most people forget; a tiny pinch adds a warm, rounded note that makes the blend taste "finished." If you have no nutmeg, leave it out. If you have no marjoram, use oregano, which is a stronger cousin, or simply a little more thyme.

To make a jar for the whole holiday season, mix 2 tablespoons dried thyme, 2 tablespoons rubbed sage, 1 tablespoon marjoram, 1 1/2 teaspoons crushed rosemary, 3/4 teaspoon black pepper and 1/2 teaspoon ground nutmeg. That makes about 6 tablespoons, enough for several batches of stuffing and gravy. Dried herbs fade over months, so if your jars are a few years old, use a bit more and taste.

Dried Sage + Dried Thyme

  • Swap: 1 teaspoon poultry seasoning → 1/2 teaspoon dried rubbed sage + 1/2 teaspoon dried thyme, plus a pinch of black pepper. With ground sage, use only 1/4 teaspoon.
  • Best for: Stuffing, gravy, chicken soup, pot pie, turkey burgers, roast chicken
  • Skip it for: Nothing major; you lose only the background notes of marjoram, rosemary and nutmeg

If you only have two jars, these are the two to have. Sage gives you the unmistakable Thanksgiving flavor, and thyme fills in the earthy, savory base. In a pan of stuffing or a pot of gravy, most people cannot tell this from the real blend. Add a small pinch of rosemary or nutmeg if you have one, and the gap closes further.

Pay attention to the kind of sage you have. Rubbed sage is fluffy, crumbled leaves, and it measures about like poultry seasoning. Ground sage is a fine powder that packs much more densely into a measuring spoon, so use about half as much. Too much sage turns bitter and medicinal, especially in gravy, so it is better to start low and add more at the end than to overshoot.

A Single Dried Herb

  • Swap: 1 teaspoon poultry seasoning → 1/2 teaspoon dried rubbed sage (1/4 teaspoon ground) or 3/4 teaspoon dried thyme. Taste and add more at the end.
  • Best for: Sage in stuffing, sausage, meatloaf and gravy; thyme in chicken soup, pot pie, roast chicken, beans and roasted vegetables
  • Skip it for: Rosemary alone at full strength, which overwhelms the dish

One herb will not taste exactly like the blend, but the right herb for the dish gets you most of the way there. For stuffing, sage is the one to reach for, because it is the flavor people expect. Use less than a full measure, since sage alone is strong. A pinch of black pepper helps fill out the flavor.

For chicken soup, pot pie and anything where the poultry seasoning is a background note, thyme is the better single choice. It is earthy and savory without the sharp edge of sage, and it is very hard to overdo. If dried rosemary is the only herb you have, use about 1/4 teaspoon per teaspoon of poultry seasoning, crush it well, and save it for roasts. Our rosemary substitutes guide covers how it behaves in different dishes.

Fresh Herbs

  • Swap: 1 teaspoon poultry seasoning → 1 tablespoon finely chopped fresh herbs: about 1 1/2 teaspoons thyme leaves, 1 teaspoon sage and 1/2 teaspoon rosemary
  • Best for: Herb butter under the skin of a turkey or chicken, stuffing, pan gravy, roasted vegetables
  • Skip it for: Dry rubs and spice mixes that need to be stored, and quick gravies where whole leaves would float on top

Fresh herbs contain a lot of water, so you need more of them. University of Illinois Extension gives the standard rule: about three times as much fresh as dried, a 3:1 ratio, so 1 tablespoon of chopped fresh herbs for each teaspoon of dried. Many grocery stores sell a "poultry blend" package of fresh sage, thyme and rosemary around the holidays, which is exactly what you want here.

Sage, thyme and rosemary are sturdy herbs that hold up well to long roasting and baking, so they can go in at the start. Chop sage finely, since whole fresh leaves can be chewy and intense in a bite. For a roast turkey or chicken, mix the chopped herbs into softened butter with a little salt and pepper, then spread it under the skin; it flavors the meat directly and the drippings make excellent gravy. If you have a bunch of fresh herbs left over after the holiday, here is how to stop letting fresh herbs die in the fridge.

Take the Guesswork Out of Eating Well

Eat Well Planner helps you organize your favorite recipes, plan balanced meals, and automatically generate shopping lists — all in one place. Whether you're tracking macros, managing dietary restrictions, or just trying to stop asking "what's for dinner?", we've got you covered.

Our AI-powered tools can adapt any recipe to your dietary needs, help you discover new meals you'll love, and even log your nutrition effortlessly. It's meal planning made simple.

Start Organizing Your Meals — Free

Italian Seasoning + Sage

  • Swap: 1 teaspoon poultry seasoning → 3/4 teaspoon Italian seasoning + 1/4 teaspoon dried rubbed sage. Without sage, use Italian seasoning 1:1 for roasts and soups.
  • Best for: Roast chicken, chicken soup, pot pie, meatloaf, turkey burgers, roasted vegetables
  • Skip it for: Stuffing without the added sage; it will taste more like a pizza herb mix than Thanksgiving

Italian seasoning shares three of poultry seasoning's herbs: thyme, marjoram and rosemary. The difference is that it leads with oregano and basil, which give it a Mediterranean, tomato-sauce feel. Adding a little sage moves it back toward the flavor of a holiday roast. For chicken soup or a weeknight roast chicken, plain Italian seasoning is fine on its own; it will just taste a little more Italian.

Some Italian seasoning blends also contain garlic powder or red pepper flakes, which are fine in a roast but less welcome in a delicate gravy. Check your jar. If you are out of Italian seasoning too, our Italian seasoning substitutes guide has a homemade version.

Herbes de Provence

  • Swap: 1 teaspoon poultry seasoning → 3/4 teaspoon herbes de Provence + a pinch of dried rubbed sage
  • Best for: Roast chicken and turkey, roasted potatoes and root vegetables, chicken stews
  • Skip it for: Gravy and stuffing if your blend has a lot of lavender

Herbes de Provence is built on thyme, rosemary, marjoram and savory, which overlap a lot with poultry seasoning. French cooks use it on roast chicken all the time, so it is a natural fit for any roast bird. The catch is lavender: many versions include it, and its floral note works well on a crisp chicken skin but can taste soapy in a creamy gravy or a pan of stuffing.

Look at your jar. If you can see small purple-gray buds, that is lavender. Pick out the obvious ones, use a little less of the blend, and add a pinch of sage to steer it back toward the classic flavor.

Bell's Seasoning

  • Swap: 1 teaspoon poultry seasoning → 1 teaspoon Bell's Seasoning
  • Best for: Stuffing, roast turkey and chicken, gravy, chicken salad, meatloaf
  • Skip it for: Nothing in particular, though the ginger gives it a slightly warmer, spicier note

If you live in New England, this little yellow box with the turkey on it may already be in your cabinet. Bell's is a poultry seasoning in its own right, and it has a long history. According to Chowhound, it debuted in Boston in 1867, started out as a sausage seasoning, and was later turned into a salt-free poultry seasoning. Its blend is rosemary, marjoram, oregano, sage, thyme, pepper and ground ginger, so it covers the same ground as standard poultry seasoning with a slightly different accent.

Because it is salt-free, it is an even swap with no adjustments needed. The same article notes that production stopped for a while in 2024 and 2025 after the brand was sold, so it may be harder to find in some stores. If you have a box, though, use it the same way.

Sage Breakfast Sausage (for Stuffing)

  • Swap: 1 1/2 teaspoons poultry seasoning in a 12-cup batch of stuffing → 8 ounces sage-seasoned bulk breakfast sausage, browned and crumbled, plus 1/2 teaspoon dried thyme. Reduce the salt in the recipe and taste before adding more.
  • Best for: Bread stuffing and dressing, cornbread stuffing
  • Skip it for: Everything else, and any vegetarian stuffing

Classic American breakfast sausage is seasoned mainly with sage and black pepper, which is most of what poultry seasoning brings to a stuffing. Brown it in the pan before you cook the celery and onions, then use the fat that renders out in place of some of the butter. You get the sage flavor and a savory, meaty richness at the same time. This is how many families make their stuffing anyway.

The trade-off is honest: sausage adds saturated fat and quite a bit of salt, so it is a flavor shortcut, not a healthier one. Cut back on the butter and salt in the recipe to compensate. If you want the sausage flavor with less fat, look for a turkey or chicken breakfast sausage.

What About the Health Side?

Poultry seasoning is used by the teaspoon, so swapping one herb blend for another does not change a dish's nutrition in any meaningful way. A few things are still worth knowing, especially around the holidays.

  • Plain herb blends are salt-free; many "poultry rubs" are not: Standard poultry seasoning and Bell's are just herbs and spices. Turkey rubs, brine kits, seasoned salt and chicken bouillon powder are a different story, and salt is often their main ingredient. Building your own blend from single herbs keeps you in control of the salt.
  • Herbs help you use less salt: A dish full of sage, thyme, onion and celery tastes complete with less salt. In a 20-week randomized trial summarized by Harvard's Nutrition Source, 40 adults coached to cook with spices and herbs in place of salt ended up excreting about 957 mg less sodium per day than a self-directed control group. It was a small study, but it is a good reason to be generous with herbs in stuffing and gravy, which can be among the saltiest dishes on the table.
  • Fresh herbs add plant variety: Sage, thyme and rosemary each count toward the "30 plants a week" idea from gut-health research, even if only in small amounts. Our post on what happens inside your body when you eat 30 plants a week explains the thinking.

The bigger nutrition wins in a holiday meal are in the dish, not the seasoning: whole-grain bread, more vegetables and less butter in the stuffing, or a gravy made from a flavorful homemade stock. Our healthier Thanksgiving stuffing and healthier mashed potatoes and gravy makeovers show what that looks like in practice. If the gravy is the problem because you are out of broth, the chicken broth substitutes guide has you covered.

What Not to Use

  • Chicken bouillon powder or "chicken seasoning": The names sound similar, but bouillon is mostly salt and flavor enhancers with very few herbs. A teaspoon in place of poultry seasoning can over-salt a whole pan of stuffing.
  • Seasoned salt or turkey rubs: Usually salt first, then paprika, garlic and onion. They do not taste like sage and thyme, and they add a lot of sodium.
  • Ground sage measured like rubbed sage: Ground sage packs about twice as densely. Measured 1:1, it makes gravy bitter and medicinal.
  • Dried rosemary at full strength: On its own, measured 1:1, it overwhelms everything. Use about a quarter of the amount and crush it well.
  • Pumpkin pie spice: It does contain nutmeg, but it is mostly cinnamon and ginger, so it pushes stuffing toward dessert.
  • Cajun seasoning: It has a bit of thyme, but paprika, cayenne and garlic take over and many versions are heavily salted.

Which Poultry Seasoning Substitute Should You Use?

If you have dried thyme, sage and a couple of other herbs, mix the homemade blend; it takes two minutes and tastes fresher than an old jar. If you only have sage and thyme, use equal parts and you will cover stuffing, gravy and soup without anyone noticing. For a roast turkey or chicken, fresh herbs in butter are an upgrade, not a compromise, and Italian seasoning or herbes de Provence with a pinch of sage will do the job too. For stuffing in a hurry, sage alone or half a pound of sage sausage gets the classic flavor in. And with any store-bought rub or seasoned blend, check the label for salt before you season the rest of the dish.

If you are not sure which option fits the recipe in front of you, ask Eat Well Planner's AI recipe chat something like "I'm out of poultry seasoning, what should I use in this stuffing?" It answers with your actual recipe in context, including the herbs and salt already in it. And if you are planning the whole holiday menu, Make It Healthier suggests ingredient swaps for dishes like stuffing, gravy or chicken pot pie and checks each one against the nutrition score before showing it to you, so you know the change is actually worth making.

Weekly Tips, Free Forever

Eat Better Without
Overthinking It

More holiday kitchen rescues like this — plus gut-friendly recipes and meal plans for the busy season ahead.