All Substitution Guides

9 Substitutes for Sweet Potatoes (for Roasting, Mashing, Pies, and Baking)

Substitution Guide
9 Substitutes for Sweet Potatoes (for Roasting, Mashing, Pies, and Baking)

Maybe the store's sweet potato bin was picked clean the week before Thanksgiving. Maybe the two you bought last week went soft and sprouty in the pantry. Or maybe someone at the table just doesn't like them, and you want the dish anyway. Whatever the reason, sweet potatoes are easy to replace once you know what job they're doing in your recipe.

That job varies a lot. In roasted vegetables and fries, sweet potatoes bring sweetness and caramelized edges. In mashes and casseroles, they're a dense, creamy, starchy base. In pies, muffins, and quick breads, they're a moist, naturally sweet puree. And in soups, curries, and chili, they add body and a little sweetness. Some substitutes cover all four jobs, while others are great at one and bad at the rest, so every option below says what it's good for and what to skip.

Useful numbers before you start: a pound of sweet potatoes is about 3 medium potatoes and makes roughly 2 cups mashed. Unless a section says otherwise, the swaps below replace sweet potatoes 1:1 by weight for roasting and soups, and 1:1 by volume for mashed or pureed sweet potato.

The Quick List

  • Butternut squash — the best all-around swap for roasting, mashing, soups, and pie
  • Kabocha squash — the closest match in texture: dense, dry, sweet, and fluffy
  • Another kind of sweet potato — Japanese, white, or purple sweet potatoes swap in directly
  • Carrots — sweet, colorful, and the best match for beta-carotene; great roasted and in soups
  • Canned pumpkin puree — the easiest swap for pie, muffins, quick breads, and soups
  • Yukon Gold or russet potatoes — the savory swap for fries, wedges, mash, and hash
  • Parsnips — sweet and nutty; excellent roasted, as fries, or blended into mash
  • Acorn or delicata squash — the swap for stuffed sweet potatoes and roasted rings or wedges
  • Canned sweet potatoes — a shortcut for casseroles and pies (watch the added sugar)

First, Check the "Yams"

Before you swap anything, look again at the produce section. Most of the orange-fleshed "yams" sold in American supermarkets are sweet potatoes. According to the LSU AgCenter, the name came from "nyami," a Senegalese word used by enslaved Africans in the American South. It caught on in the 1930s, when Louisiana researchers used "yam" in a national marketing campaign to set their moist, orange-fleshed sweet potatoes apart from the firmer white-fleshed types grown farther north. The USDA still requires packages labeled "yams" to also say "sweet potatoes." Canned "cut yams" are sweet potatoes too.

So if the store is out of "sweet potatoes" but has a pile of Garnet or Jewel "yams," buy those. They're the same thing, and you don't need to change the recipe.

True yams are a different plant. They're usually found in Latin American, African, Caribbean, and Asian markets, often under names like ñame or name. They have rough, bark-like skin and white or pale flesh, and the LSU AgCenter notes they're starchier than sweet potatoes, with little of their beta-carotene. A true yam works where you'd boil, mash, or fry a starchy potato, but it isn't a good swap for a sweet potato pie or casserole. More on that in the "What Not to Use" section.

Which Substitute for Which Dish

  • Roasted cubes or wedges: butternut squash, kabocha, carrots, parsnips, delicata, or Yukon Gold potatoes
  • Fries: russet potatoes for crispness, or parsnips or carrots for sweetness
  • Mashed sweet potatoes: kabocha, butternut squash, or a half-and-half mash of carrots and Yukon Golds
  • Sweet potato casserole: roasted butternut or kabocha, mashed; canned sweet potatoes in a pinch
  • Sweet potato pie: canned pumpkin puree, butternut squash puree, or kabocha puree
  • Muffins, quick breads, pancakes, brownies: canned pumpkin puree or butternut squash puree
  • Soups, curries, chili, stews: butternut squash, kabocha, carrots, or canned pumpkin to thicken
  • Baked and stuffed whole: acorn squash halves, or russet potatoes for savory fillings

Butternut Squash

  • Swap: 1:1 by weight for roasting and soups; 1:1 by volume for mashed or pureed sweet potato
  • Best for: Roasting, soups, curries, casseroles, mash, pie, muffins, and quick breads
  • Skip it for: Crispy fries. It browns well but stays soft
  • Health notes: 40 calories, 10.5 g carbs, and 3.2 g fiber per 100 g baked, compared with 90 calories, 20.7 g carbs, and 3.3 g fiber for baked sweet potato. Same fiber, under half the calories

If you only remember one swap, make it this one. Butternut squash has the same orange color, a similar sweet and nutty flavor, and it cooks in about the same time. Peel it, scoop out the seeds, and cut it into the same size pieces your recipe calls for. Cubes roast at 400 to 425°F in 25 to 35 minutes, about the same as sweet potato. Many stores sell it already peeled and cubed, which makes it an easy weeknight swap.

The main difference is water. Butternut has less starch and more moisture than sweet potato, so a mash or pie filling can come out looser. Roast the squash for mash or puree instead of boiling it. If the puree still looks wet, drain it in a fine-mesh strainer for 15 to 30 minutes or stir it in a skillet over medium heat until it thickens. For a casserole, add any milk or cream a little at a time and stop once it looks right. You'll usually need less than the recipe says.

Kabocha Squash

  • Swap: 1:1 by weight for roasting; 1:1 by volume for mashed or pureed sweet potato
  • Best for: Mash, roasting, curries, soups, casseroles, pie, and tempura
  • Skip it for: Fries (it's hard to cut into sticks and won't crisp)
  • Health notes: Like other winter squash, it has fewer calories and carbs than sweet potato, plus beta-carotene from its orange flesh

Kabocha, sometimes called Japanese pumpkin, is the squash that tastes and feels the most like sweet potato. It's dense, dry, and starchy, with a sweet flavor often compared to chestnuts. Roasted kabocha mashes into something very close to mashed sweet potato without any draining. If your butternut mash usually comes out watery, kabocha solves that.

The squat green shell is hard to cut. Microwave the whole squash for 2 to 3 minutes to soften it a little before you use a knife. You don't need to peel it: the skin is edible and softens completely when roasted, so wedges can go into the oven skin-on at 400 to 425°F for about 25 to 35 minutes. Kabocha can vary from creamy to a little chalky, so taste a piece once it's cooked. If it's dry, add an extra splash of liquid to the mash.

Another Kind of Sweet Potato

  • Swap: 1:1 by weight or volume
  • Best for: Everything sweet potatoes do
  • Skip it for: Nothing, but expect a different color and a drier texture
  • Health notes: White- and yellow-fleshed sweet potatoes have much less beta-carotene than orange ones; purple ones bring anthocyanins instead

If your recipe means the orange Garnet or Jewel sweet potato and the store has a different kind, use it. Japanese sweet potatoes (satsumaimo) have purple-red skin and pale yellow flesh. They're drier, fluffier, and chestnut-sweet, and they make excellent roasted wedges and fries. White sweet potatoes such as Hannah are mild and a bit starchier. Purple sweet potatoes such as Stokes are dense and dry and turn a pie or mash a striking violet.

All three are drier than orange sweet potatoes. For mash or pie, add an extra tablespoon or two of milk or butter per pound until it looks right. They can also take about 5 to 10 minutes longer to soften when roasted whole.

Carrots

  • Swap: 1:1 by weight for roasting and soups; for mash, use half carrots and half Yukon Gold potatoes
  • Best for: Roasting, soups, stews, curries, and grated into muffins and quick breads
  • Skip it for: Mash on their own (watery and fibrous) and baked whole or stuffed
  • Health notes: The vitamin A match: about 856 mcg RAE per 100 g cooked, close to sweet potato's 961, with 31 calories and 3 g fiber

If you want the color and the beta-carotene, carrots come closest. Cut them into 1/2-inch coins or sticks and roast at 425°F for 25 to 30 minutes, or use them pound for pound in soups and curries. In a pureed sweet potato soup, carrots give the same color and nearly the same sweetness.

Carrots don't have enough starch to make a creamy mash on their own. The fix is to boil equal weights of carrots and Yukon Gold potatoes together until both are very tender, then mash. The potatoes add creaminess and the carrots add color and sweetness, so the result is surprisingly close to mashed sweet potato. In muffins and quick breads that call for grated raw sweet potato, grated carrot swaps in 1:1. Carrot fries are tasty, but they soften instead of crisping.

Canned Pumpkin Puree

  • Swap: 1 cup mashed sweet potato → 1 cup canned pumpkin puree (a 15-ounce can is about 1 3/4 cups)
  • Best for: Sweet potato pie, muffins, quick breads, pancakes, brownies, and blended soups
  • Skip it for: Anything roasted, fried, or chunky
  • Health notes: 83 calories, 7.1 g fiber, and 1,906 mcg RAE vitamin A per cup, so it's lighter than mashed sweet potato with plenty of beta-carotene

For pie and baking, this is the easiest swap, and you may already have a can in the pantry. Sweet potato pie and pumpkin pie are close cousins and use nearly the same custard, so canned pumpkin goes in cup for cup. Expect a slightly softer, silkier, less sweet filling, since pumpkin has less starch and sugar than sweet potato. Taste the filling before adding the eggs and stir in a tablespoon or two of brown sugar if you want it sweeter. Muffins and quick breads come out moist and a little denser. If you want to compare recipes, our healthier pumpkin pie shows how close the two pies really are.

Make sure the can says pumpkin puree, not pumpkin pie filling. Pie filling is already sweetened and spiced, so it doesn't belong in savory dishes, and in a sweet recipe you'd need to cut the sugar and spices. If you're out of canned pumpkin too, our pumpkin puree substitutes guide covers what else works, and most of those options also work for sweet potato.

Yukon Gold or Russet Potatoes

  • Swap: 1:1 by weight
  • Best for: Fries, wedges, hash, savory mash, roasted cubes, and baked potatoes with savory toppings
  • Skip it for: Pie, sweet baking, and anything with a brown sugar or marshmallow topping
  • Health notes: Similar calories (93 per 100 g baked) and more potassium, but less fiber (2.2 g) and almost no vitamin A

In savory dishes, regular potatoes work fine as long as you don't need sweetness or color. Russets make the crispiest fries and the fluffiest baked potatoes, so use them for sweet potato fries, wedges, or a loaded baked sweet potato with chili or black beans. Yukon Golds are the best all-purpose choice: buttery, creamy when mashed, and firm enough to hold their shape in a roast or hash. Cooking times are about the same.

What you lose is the sweetness that makes sweet potatoes taste caramelized. A drizzle of maple syrup or honey in the last 10 minutes of roasting, or a pinch of smoked paprika, helps make up for it. If you're making a potato salad or grain bowl ahead of time, cooked and chilled potatoes develop resistant starch, which is good for your gut.

Parsnips

  • Swap: 1:1 by weight; for mash, use half parsnips and half potatoes
  • Best for: Roasting, fries, soups, and mixed into mash
  • Skip it for: Pie and sweet baking (the flavor is earthy and slightly peppery)
  • Health notes: 71 calories and 3.6 g fiber per 100 g cooked, plus folate and vitamin C, but no vitamin A

Parsnips look like pale carrots and taste sweet and nutty, with a spicy, almost herbal edge. They caramelize beautifully, so they're a great match for roasted sweet potatoes or sweet potato fries. Peel them and cut them into even sticks or chunks. With big parsnips, cut out the woody core in the thick end. They cook a little faster than sweet potatoes, so start checking roasted parsnips at about 20 minutes at 425°F.

On their own, parsnips make a dense, fibrous mash. Boiled with an equal weight of Yukon Golds, they make a sweet and creamy one. They're also excellent with carrots in a roasted root vegetable tray.

Acorn or Delicata Squash

  • Swap: 1 medium sweet potato (baked and stuffed) → 1/2 acorn squash; for roasting, 1:1 by weight
  • Best for: Baked and stuffed, roasted halves, roasted rings or wedges, and grain bowls
  • Skip it for: Mash, pie, and baking (watery and less sweet)
  • Health notes: The fiber winner: 4.4 g fiber and 56 calories per 100 g baked, though acorn's pale flesh has very little vitamin A

If your recipe calls for baked sweet potatoes split open and stuffed with chili, black beans, or a grain filling, acorn squash halves are a natural swap. The scooped-out seed cavity is already a bowl. Brush the cut sides with oil and roast cut-side down at 400°F for 30 to 40 minutes, until a fork slides in easily, then fill and serve.

Delicata is the easiest winter squash to cook: the skin is thin and edible, so you just halve it, scoop out the seeds, slice it into half-moons, and roast at 425°F for 20 to 25 minutes. It's sweet and creamy, and it's a good swap for roasted sweet potato in salads, grain bowls, and sheet-pan dinners.

Canned Sweet Potatoes

  • Swap: Drained and mashed, 1:1 by volume for mashed sweet potato
  • Best for: Sweet potato casserole, pie, and quick breads
  • Skip it for: Roasting, fries, and savory dishes when they're packed in syrup
  • Health notes: Syrup-packed cans add sugar; choose sweet potatoes packed in water or vacuum-packed when you can

Canned "cut yams" and sweet potatoes are already cooked and soft, so they're ideal for a casserole or pie where everything gets mashed anyway. Drain them well, rinse syrup-packed ones, and measure after mashing. If the can was packed in syrup, reduce the sugar in your recipe. Taste before adding the full amount, since you may only need half. Our healthier sweet potato casserole goes further, trading the brown sugar for orange and the marshmallows for a pecan-oat crumble.

Canned sweet potatoes are too soft to roast into crisp-edged cubes, and syrup-packed ones taste out of place in savory dishes like curry or chili.

How the Swaps Compare Nutritionally

Sweet potatoes are known for beta-carotene, and they deserve it: a 100 g serving of baked sweet potato has 961 mcg RAE of vitamin A, more than a full day's Daily Value of 900 mcg. They also have 3.3 g of fiber and 475 mg of potassium. If beta-carotene matters to you, stick with orange substitutes. Here's how they compare per 100 g cooked:

  • Sweet potato (baked): 90 calories, 20.7 g carbs, 3.3 g fiber, 961 mcg RAE vitamin A
  • Carrots (boiled): 31 calories, 8.3 g carbs, 3.0 g fiber, 856 mcg RAE
  • Canned pumpkin: 34 calories, 8.1 g carbs, 2.9 g fiber, 778 mcg RAE
  • Butternut squash (baked): 40 calories, 10.5 g carbs, 3.2 g fiber, 558 mcg RAE
  • Acorn squash (baked): 56 calories, 14.6 g carbs, 4.4 g fiber, 21 mcg RAE
  • Parsnips (boiled): 71 calories, 17.0 g carbs, 3.6 g fiber, 0 mcg RAE
  • Potatoes (baked, with skin): 93 calories, 21.2 g carbs, 2.2 g fiber, about 1 mcg RAE
  • True yam (cooked): 116 calories, 27.5 g carbs, 3.9 g fiber, about 6 mcg RAE

A few things stand out. Carrots, canned pumpkin, and butternut squash keep most of the vitamin A and nearly all the fiber at well under half the calories and carbs, so they're useful swaps if you want a lighter side dish. Acorn squash and parsnips actually have more fiber than sweet potatoes, but almost no vitamin A. Regular potatoes have about as many calories, less fiber, and almost no vitamin A, though they do have more potassium. None of these swaps is a bad choice, but they aren't equal.

Swapping is also an easy way to add plant variety. If you usually reach for sweet potatoes, using kabocha or parsnips once in a while counts toward the "30 plants a week" goal that Eat Well Planner's Plant Points tracker is built around.

Which Swap Fits Your Recipe?

The right substitute depends on the rest of the dish. A sweet potato curry with coconut milk needs a different swap than a sweet potato hash with chorizo, and a guide like this one can only speak in general terms. In Eat Well Planner, you can ask the AI recipe chat right from your saved recipe ("I'm making this sweet potato chili and I'm out of sweet potatoes — what should I use?") and get an answer that accounts for everything else in the pot. Or open the recipe in the Recipe Playground, swap in butternut squash or carrots, and watch the nutrition score change before you shop.

Take the Guesswork Out of Eating Well

Eat Well Planner helps you organize your favorite recipes, plan balanced meals, and automatically generate shopping lists — all in one place. Whether you're tracking macros, managing dietary restrictions, or just trying to stop asking "what's for dinner?", we've got you covered.

Our AI-powered tools can adapt any recipe to your dietary needs, help you discover new meals you'll love, and even log your nutrition effortlessly. It's meal planning made simple.

Start Organizing Your Meals — Free

What Not to Use

  • True yams in sweet dishes. They're starchy and mild, not sweet, and a yam pie comes out bland and gluey. Use them like potatoes instead.
  • Carving pumpkins. The big Halloween kind is watery, stringy, and bland. Use small pie pumpkins or canned puree.
  • Spaghetti squash. It cooks into watery strands, so it won't mash, puree smoothly, or hold together in a pie.
  • Pumpkin pie filling in savory recipes. It's already sweetened and spiced. Use plain pumpkin puree.
  • Syrup-packed canned sweet potatoes in curry, chili, or hash. The syrup makes savory dishes taste candied, and the soft pieces fall apart.
  • Turnips or rutabaga as the only swap in sweet dishes. Their sharp, slightly bitter flavor works in a savory mash with potatoes, not in a casserole or pie.

The Bottom Line

First, check whether the store's "yams" are actually sweet potatoes, because they usually are. If not, butternut squash is the best all-around swap, and kabocha is the best match for mash and casseroles. Canned pumpkin is the easiest choice for pie and baking, carrots are the closest match for beta-carotene, and regular potatoes or parsnips work well in savory roasts and fries. Many of these swaps have fewer calories and the same or more fiber than sweet potatoes, so you may like the result even more than the original.

And if you want to go further than one ingredient, Eat Well Planner can create a recipe variation with the swap already worked in, including amounts and cooking times. Or try Make It Healthier, which suggests ingredient swaps and checks how much each one actually improves the recipe's nutrition before it shows them to you.

Weekly Tips, Free Forever

Eat Better Without
Overthinking It

More kitchen saves like these — plus gut-friendly recipes and meal plans for holiday cooking and every week after.